SUMMARY: Efforts to frame conservation interventions in terms of idealized outcomes that benefit both human well-being and biodiversity, and the rhetoric of consensus that often accompanies these, have been criticized. Acknowledgement of trade–offs between often incommensurable interests and perspectives, has been argued to be more democratic and transparent. This paper critically examines calls to consensus in conservation on the Galápagos Islands, where the population has been urged to unite around a shared vision of conservation in order to secure a sustainable future. Q methodology was used to examine the discourses of conservation on the islands, and to assess whether a shared vision of Galápagos is either achievable or desirable. Thirty-three participants carried out Q sorts about Galápagos conservation. Three discourses emerged from the analysis: conservation of Galápagos as an international/global concern; conservation linked with sustainable development; and social welfare and equitable development. The results highlight the subjective and political nature of the different discourses, and the paper concludes that calls to consensus or shared visions, while seductive in their promise of harmonious cooperation for conservation, can be read as attempts to depoliticize debates around conservation, and as such should be treated with caution.
Vulnerabilities in local food systems revealed by the COVID-19 pandemic were especially evident in highly tourism-dependent islands. This underscores the crucial role of agriculture in ensuring socio-ecological resilience, food security, and livelihood options in these contexts. Yet despite renewed policy attention, sustaining local farming in remote island settings continues to face numerous challenges. Amid growing recognition of the ways in which collective imagination shapes (and constrains) sustainability transformations, this paper applies the conceptual lens of imaginaries to examine agricultural futures in the Galápagos Islands and to explore the question of why agriculture remains marginal, despite widespread acknowledgement that supporting sustainable farming is central to the archipelago’s long-term sustainability. Through reflexive thematic analysis of policy documents, grey literature, and semi-structured interviews, the paper shows how imaginative spaces of possibility around food futures in Galápagos are conditioned by the powerful entanglement of hegemonic conservationist imaginaries with touristic imaginaries of an uninhabited wilderness. Within this contested terrain, five overlapping and co-constituting imaginaries of agriculture are distinguished, oriented variously around conservation priorities, technocratic planning, entrepreneurial growth, traditional livelihoods, and agroecological transformation. The analysis highlights how these imaginaries mobilize contrasting logics of support and mechanisms of change and illustrates how they complicate simplistic binaries, for example, between pristine and human-managed ecosystems, or between technological and holistic approaches to farming. The paper underscores the importance of paying critical attention to imaginaries of agriculture in order to navigate pathways toward more sustainable and resilient food systems in ecologically fragile island contexts.