Prosthesis users often make a choice between a myoelectric or body-powered upper-limb prosthesis. The choice may be determined using factors such as cost, insurance limitations, function, sensory feedback, and cosmesis. An updated systematic review was conducted to determine differences between myoelectric and body-powered prostheses in the past 3 years (mid-2013 to 2016) since the previous review. An additional 43 unique publications were identified. Ultimately, three of the publications were included, adding evidence to two previously developed empirical evidence statements regarding the potential need for multiple control strategies to facilitate intuitive prosthetic control and the value of task training in improving function. However, there is still insufficient evidence to conclude that either the myoelectric or body-powered prosthesis provides an overall advantage. Although excluded from this literature review, research on hybrid prostheses such as the DEKA arm and on sensation and haptic feedback is emerging. There is still a need for more empirical evidence regarding functional differences in upper-limb prostheses.
25 February 2014 in Prosthetics and Orthotics International
Typical upper limb prostheses may limit sports participation; therefore, specialized terminal devices are often needed. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the ability of transradial amputees to play golf using a specialized terminal device. Club head speed, X-factor, and elbow motion of two individuals with transradial amputations using an Eagle Golf terminal device were compared to a non-amputee during a golf swing. Measurements were collected pre/post training with various stances and grips. Both prosthesis users preferred a right-handed stance initially; however, after training, one preferred a left-handed stance. The amputees had slower club head speeds and a lower X-factor compared to the non-amputee golfer, but increased their individual elbow motion on the prosthetic side after training. Amputees enjoyed using the device, and it may provide kinematic benefits indicated by the increase in elbow flexion on the prosthetic side. The transradial amputees were able to swing a golf club with sufficient repetition, form, and velocity to play golf recreationally. Increased elbow flexion on the prosthetic side suggests a potential benefit from using the Eagle Golf terminal device. Participating in recreational sports can increase amputees’ health and quality of life.
Introduction: Many military service members and civilians suffer from lower extremity trauma. Despite recent advancements in lower limb bracing technology, it remains unclear whether these newer advanced braces offer improved comfort and functionality compared to conventional options. The IDEO (Intrepid Dynamic Exoskeletal Orthosis), a type of “advanced” orthosis was developed to assist in maintaining high functional performance in patients who have experienced high-energy lower extremity trauma and underwent limb salvage surgeries.Methods: A cross-sector multi-site initiative was completed to study the efficacy of advanced ankle foot orthoses (AFO) for lower limb trauma and injury compared to a conventional AFO. Following fitting, training, and accommodation, the subjects were assessed in each AFO system for mobility, self-reported function, safety and pain, and preference.Results: They preferred the advanced over the conventional AFO and the mobility and exertion perception improved with the advanced AFO with no difference in pain or overall health status scores.Discussion: Thus, an advanced AFO is an option for trauma affecting the lower limb. Long-term studies are required to better understand the accommodation and learning process of using an advanced AFO.