Stress is a significant public health burden in the United States, with most Americans reporting unhealthy levels of stress. Stress management techniques include various evidence-based treatments shown to be effective but with heterogeneous treatment responses, indicating a lack of uniform benefits for all individuals. Designed to assess a participant’s response to a specific intervention, personalized (N-of-1) trials provide guidance for which treatment (s) work (s) best for the individual. Prior studies examining the effects of mindfulness meditation, yoga, and walking for stress reduction found all three interventions to be associated with significant reductions in self-reported measures of stress. Delivering these treatments using a personalized trial approach has the potential to assist clinicians in identifying the best stress management techniques for individuals with persistently high stress while fostering treatment decisions that consider their personal condition/barriers. This trial will evaluate a personalized approach compared to standard of care for three interventions (guided mindfulness meditation; guided yoga; and guided brisk walking) to manage perceived stress. Participants will respond to daily surveys and wear a Fitbit device for 18 weeks. After a 2-week baseline period, participants in the personalized trial groups will receive 12 weeks of interventions in randomized order, while participants in the standard-of-care group will have access to all interventions for self-directed stress management. After intervention, all participants will undergo 2 weeks of observation, followed by two additional weeks of the stress management intervention of their choosing while continuing outcome measurement. At study completion, all participants will be sent a satisfaction survey. The primary analysis will compare perceived stress levels between the personalized and standard of care arms. The results of this trial will provide further support for the use of personalized designs for managing stress.Clinical Trial Registration: clinicaltrials.gov, NCT05408832.Protocol version: 9/14/2022, 21-0968-MRB.
10 September 2024 in Contemporary Clinical Trials Communications
Background: Adequate sleep plays a crucial role in maintaining physical, mental, and emotional health. On average, adults require 7–9 h of sleep per night. However, less than two-thirds of women meet this recommendation. During the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic, poor sleep quality and moderate-to-severe stress were highly prevalent among healthcare workers (HCWs), especially women. While some interventions have been proposed to address stress/burnout in HCWs, few have focused specifically on women in healthcare. Therefore, this is a protocol for a study that aims to determine the efficacy of a mind–body intervention (MBI) to improve sleep duration among women HCWs aged 40–60 years using the personalized (N-of-1) trial design. Methods: A personalized (N-of-1) trials model will be employed to evaluate the efficacy of an MBI to improve sleep duration (primary endpoint) and explore its effects on sleep quality, physiological factors, and their relationships with participants’ perceived stress, anxiety, and depression. The series of personalized trials (n = 60) will be conducted over 16 weeks. The MBI will include mindfulness, yoga, and guided walking, delivered in two 2-week block sequences for 12 weeks, with two 2-week periods for baseline and follow-up. Participants will watch 30-min videos three times weekly and wear an activity tracker to monitor sleep and activity. They will receive daily text messages with questions about sleep quality and bi-weekly questionnaires about their stress, anxiety and depression scores, fatigue, concentration, confidence, mood, and pain levels. Conclusion: Results from this study will inform the development of N-of-1 methodology for addressing the health and wellness needs of middle-aged women.
Background: Poor sleep (defined by short sleep duration or poor quality) is a common condition with potential serious health consequences. Exogenous melatonin supplements have been found to effectively improve poor sleep but have also been shown to have heterogeneity of treatment effects (HTEs) between individuals. Personalized N-of-1 trials, in which each participant is the unit of analysis, are ideal for identifying whether a treatment with high HTE is beneficial for each individual patient. Objective: This study aimed to identify the feasibility, acceptability, and effectiveness of a series of personalized N-of-1 trials of melatonin for poor sleep. Methods: This study consisted of 60 digital, personalized N-of-1 crossover trials comparing the effects of 3.0 mg and 0.5 mg of melatonin versus placebo for poor sleep with randomization to 1 of 2 orders. The trial comprised a 2-week baseline period and a 12-week intervention period. The primary outcomes were usability of the personalized trial system (measured using the System Usability Scale [SUS]) and participant satisfaction with the trial. Effectiveness outcomes included sleep duration (measured using a Fitbit activity tracker [Google]) and sleep quality (measured using the consensus sleep diary). Results: Participants rated the usability of the personalized trial as acceptable (average SUS score 76.3, SD 17.1), and 96% (55/57) of those who completed satisfaction surveys stated that they would recommend the trial to others. Importantly, indices of HTE were low for 3.0 mg and 0.5 mg doses of melatonin, indicating that the effect of these treatments on sleep duration and sleep quality did not substantially vary between participants and that averaged treatment responses are appropriate. Averaged participant sleep duration did not significantly differ between the 3.0 mg (P=.70) and 0.5 mg (P=.90) melatonin intervention periods and the baseline period. In addition, regression models did not show differences between different levels of melatonin and placebo periods for sleep duration or quality. Conclusions: Participant ratings of the usability of and satisfaction with this series of personalized N-of-1 trials of melatonin for sleep suggest these trials are both feasible and acceptable. However, our results show that melatonin supplements did not significantly improve sleep duration or sleep quality. Furthermore, the treatment effects’ lack of heterogeneity among participants suggests that future use of N-of-1 trials of melatonin for poor sleep is not needed.
Introduction Cardiovascular disease (CVD) is the leading cause of mortality worldwide, though it may be prevented by increasing physical activity (PA). When behaviour change techniques (BCTs) are bundled together, they increase PA, though which individual BCTs increase PA (and the behavioural mechanism of action (MoA) responsible for said increase) have not been studied. The aim of this study is to conduct a randomised factorial experiment to determine which of four BCTs significantly engage the proposed MoA—self-efficacy for PA—in adults at risk for CVD. Methods and analysis Eight hundred and twenty sedentary adults (18–74 years old) at risk for CVD will be recruited between September 2022 and June 2025 to a fully remote, 24-week randomised BCT intervention. To identify those who might benefit from this intervention, we define self-reported walking <7500 steps per day as ‘sedentary'. Following a 4-week run-in period to confirm sedentary behaviour and adherence to the study protocol, 624 eligible participants will be randomised to an 8-week intervention period. A full factorial randomised experiment will be conducted with 16 possible conditions: one will receive no BCTs (no-BCT condition), another will receive all four, and 14 will receive a unique combination of BCTs. During the intervention, participants will receive their randomised daily BCT(s) via text message. Daily steps will be continuously measured using an activity tracker. Self-efficacy for PA will be assessed bi-weekly via the Self-Efficacy for Walking Scale–Duration. Participants will complete a 12-week post-intervention follow-up period where steps will be monitored despite no BCTs being delivered. BCT(s) associated with increased daily step counts and increased self-efficacy for PA between run-in and study completion (week 12 of follow-up) will be determined alongside whether or not self-efficacy for PA mediates the association between each BCT and increased walking. Ethics and dissemination This trial was approved by the Northwell Health Institutional Review Board. The full factorial experimental trial results will be published in a peer-reviewed journal. Data from this clinical trial will be made available on reasonable request. Trial registration number clinicaltrials.gov; Identifier: NCT05425641, 06/21/2022
Objectives To identify the minimum effective dose of a multi-behaviour change technique (BCT) intervention to increase physical activity among individuals on primary statin therapy using the time-to-event continual reassessment method (TiTE-CRM). Setting A large New York metropolitan area healthcare system comprising approximately 85 000 employees and 5.5 million patient encounters annually. Participants 42 participants enrolled in 13 cohorts of 3 participants, 1 cohort of 2 participants and 1 cohort of 1 participant. The sample was composed of 16.7% individuals aged 66 and older (n=7), 64.3% women (n=27), 69.0% white individuals (n=29) and 7.1% Hispanic individuals (n=3). Interventions A variable-duration, four-BCT text message intervention and a 2-week follow-up. Dose assignment relied on TiTE-CRM to adjust the duration of the intervention based on adherence of participants in prior cohorts. Five mechanisms of action (MoAs) were assessed: self-efficacy, intrinsic regulation, discrepancy in behaviour, motivation and barriers to activity. Primary and secondary outcome measures The primary outcome measure was the proportion of participants who achieved a 2000 step/day increase between baseline and follow-up. The secondary outcomes were within-participant changes in daily steps (examined as a continuous variable at the daily level) and potential MoAs for increased physical activity. Results Of the 40 participants who completed follow-up, 7 (17.5%) achieved the goal of 2000 or more steps per day during their follow-up period. Though participants did increase the number of steps they walked during the intervention (B(SE)=373.1 (154.7) steps; p=0.016), there was no association between increased intervention duration and increased daily average steps. The intervention was also associated with increases in self-efficacy (p=0.002), intrinsic regulation (p=0.037), discrepancy in behaviour (p<0.001) and motivation (p=0.039). Conclusions The results of this trial did not show a traditional dose-response curve to increasing the length of a multicomponent BCT intervention. Results did show that the intervention successfully increased steps during the intervention period and that the benefit of the intervention dwindled during follow-up. Further, potential MoAs for the intervention were confirmed. Trial registration number NCT05273723.
4 September 2024 in International Journal of Behavioral Medicine