Current methods for assessing acceleration efforts (accefforts) in ice hockey do not account for the influence of initial skating speed on maximal voluntary acceleration capacity, which may lead to a biased evaluation of acceffort intensity. In this study, we introduce the conceptual approach of the relative acceleration threshold (relthreshold) to ice hockey and outline its potential benefits for the assessment of accefforts. Locomotion data derived from observations of 17 players across 10 official games were used to model the initial-skating-speed-dependent maximal voluntary acceleration capacity (amax–vinit capacity), from which a team-specific relthreshold was determined (relthreshold_75% = 3.23 − 0.365vinit), and, subsequently, applied to assess accefforts alongside a fix threshold set at 2 m·s−2 (fixthreshold_2). Differences in accefforts depended on the method used (relthreshold_75% vs. fixthreshold_2) as well as the playing position when using the relthreshold_75%. The fixthreshold_2 reported 89.1 ± 35.8% more accefforts than the relthreshold_75%. However, only one-third of these accefforts exceeded relthreshold_75%, which is considered indicative of neuromuscularly intense accefforts according to the modeled amax–vinit capacity. Moreover, at skating speeds above 4 m·s−1, the fixthreshold_2 only assessed a negligible number of accefforts, whereas the relthreshold_75% assessed 27.2 ± 9.3% of all its accefforts. In line with established theoretical rationales, the observational findings of this study suggest that an acceleration threshold adapted to the initial skating speed offers a conceptually more valid approach to assessing accefforts in ice hockey.
Modern load monitoring in soccer increasingly employs relative individualized acceleration intensity thresholds derived from individual maximal acceleration-initial running speed (amax-vinit) regression lines. This study examined the reliability and validity of soccer players' individual amax-vinit regression lines determined solely from game locomotion data. Using a GPS-based tracking system, we prospectively collected game locomotion data from 159 male youth elite soccer players over one season and repeatedly determined their amax-vinit regression lines using a recently introduced game data-based method. To examine the influence of data volume, regression lines were determined using different numbers of consecutive games. As a criterion measure, the amax-vinit regression line was determined using an acceleration test in 55 athletes. Reliability was assessed via the typical error (TE) and the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), and validity via the typical error of the estimate (TEE) and the Pearson correlation coefficient. The magnitude of errors and correlation coefficients was assessed using standardization and published thresholds, respectively. Reliability improved gradually with increasing data volume, resulting in TEs of 3.4% (amax intercept), 7.3% (vinit intercept), and 10.3% (slope). Nonetheless, all TEs were large in magnitude, and ICCs very low to low. Validity was unaffected by data volume, with TEEs consistently ~7% (amax intercept), ~ 12% (vinit intercept), and ~17% (slope). All TEEs were assessed as extremely large, and Pearson correlations as impractical. These findings indicate that the game data-based method currently lacks the precision required for individual-level applications, and this limitation cannot be resolved simply by including more games. Therefore, establishing relative individualized acceleration intensity thresholds within a team still requires a test-based approach. Moreover, the results suggest that properties inherent in GPS-based game locomotion data, rather than data volume, underlie the observed imprecision. We propose that substantial future improvements will depend on more precise tracking systems.
Monitoring athletic development in youth soccer is crucial for player evaluation, identifying training needs, and determining long-term progression. However, standard percentile assessments based on chronological age (CA) do not account for biological maturity or developmental variability. This study aimed to improve 10 m sprint performance assessment in youth soccer by integrating biological age (BA) into percentile modeling and applying linear mixed models (LMM) to capture individual development. The analysis was based on 10 m sprint data collected within the Swiss Football Association's talent development program between 2017 and 2024, comprising 9476 observations for the Lambda Mu Sigma (LMS) method and 3983 for LMMs. BA was calculated using the Mirwald method as an estimation for peak height velocity. Empirical percentile curves (LMS) were generated for both CA and BA, while LMMs established longitudinal reference curves and enabled individual performance predictions using bootstrap resampling. In males, BA explained more variance in sprint performance than CA (R2 = 0.22 vs. 0.18), whereas no significant predictors were identified for females. Percentile curves based on BA elevated rankings of late-maturing players and lowered those of early-maturing players, suggesting better consideration of developmental differences. LMMs provided a more comprehensive modeling framework than LMS, by incorporating repeated measures and individual developmental trajectories. Integrating BA and LMMs longitudinal modeling could enhance the fair evaluation of youth soccer players. Findings support individualized, maturity-adjusted monitoring, offering practical value for longer-term performance diagnostic and evaluation. This statistical approach, applied to a large practice-oriented dataset, enables targeted and sustainable improvement of youth player development.