Wearable sensors offer the opportunity for patients to perform a self-assessment of their function with respect to a variety of movement exercises. Corresponding commercial products have the potential to change the communication between patients and physiotherapists during the recovery process. Even if they turn out to be user-friendly, there remains the question to what degree the numerical results are reliable and comparable with those obtained by assessment methods traditionally used. To address this question for one specific recently developed and commercially available sensor, a method comparison study was performed. The sensor-based assessment of eight movement parameters was compared with an assessment of the same parameters based on test procedures traditionally used. Thirty-three patients recovering after arthroscopic knee surgery participated in the study. The whole assessment procedure was repeated. Reproducibility and agreement were quantified by the intra class correlation coefficient. The height of a one-leg vertical jump and the number of side hops showed high agreement between the two modalities and high reproducibility (ICC > 0.85). Due to differences in the set-up of the assessment, agreement could not be achieved for three mobility parameters, but even the correlation was only fair (r < 0.5). Knee stability showed poor agreement. Consequently, the use of the sensor can currently only be recommended for selected parameters. The variation in degree of agreement and reproducibility across different parameters clearly indicate the need for developing corresponding guidance for each new sensor put onto the market.
18 June 2021 in Sports Orthopaedics and Traumatology
Physical activity trackers are promising for monitoring physical activity in patients after surgery. However, the remobilization of patients following surgery is characterized by low-impact movements. It is often unclear to health care professionals whether a specific physical activity tracker is able to correctly detect steps in this patient population. A protocol is proposed, which allows health care professionals to familiarize themselves with the detection limits of a physical activity tracker. The professional should walk 20 steps under varying conditions mimicking the situation of patients after knee surgery. Conditions vary in step size, walking direction, use of walking aids, and footwear. The protocol was tested in a group of 14 health care professionals. Participants wore four trackers simultaneously, representing different modalities and different locations. For two trackers, the participants could experience a variation in the detection limits across the different conditions. On one hand, the within-participant reproducibility was substantial on average, though the between-participant reproducibility was only fair. On the other hand, experiencing incorrect step counts varied highly across and within participants. In conclusion, the self-familiarization of health care professionals with the detection limits of a physical activity tracker using specific protocols seems to be a feasible approach. Such protocols can provide valuable tools for facilitating the use of physical activity trackers in clinical applications. Additional research may allow for further refinement of the protocol to generate input that is more comparable across participants and closer to the gait of patients.