Background/Objectives: Evidence on the association between adiposity and postural stability (PS) in children is inconsistent, partly because most studies rely on single indices such as body mass index (BMI). We examined whether preadolescent girls stratified by a multivariate anthropometric adiposity profile differ in static PS. Methods: In this cross-sectional study, 235 girls aged 9–12 years were assigned to three subgroups by Ward's hierarchical cluster analysis of BMI, three skinfold thicknesses and three segment circumferences. Sway area and centre of pressure (COP) path length were recorded in double-leg, right single-leg and left single-leg stance. Group differences were analysed using MANCOVA, with habitual physical activity (PAQ-C) as a covariate. Results: A significant multivariate group effect on PS was found (Pillai's trace = 0.671, p < 0.001, η²p = 0.335), independent of physical activity. Sway area and COP path length decreased consistently from the lowest- to the highest-adiposity subgroup, with the largest effects in left single-leg stance (η²p = 0.381–0.464). Conclusions: Girls with a higher composite adiposity profile exhibited smaller sway excursions across all stance conditions, independent of physical activity. The pattern was most pronounced under the most demanding stance condition and aligns with biomechanical models linking greater segmental mass to a stiffer ankle strategy and an enlarged base of support. Future longitudinal studies with objective body composition and maturation assessment are needed to clarify the mechanisms underlying this relationship.