Floodplains are widely promoted as a central component of flood management, expected to attenuate flood peaks and reduce downstream risk. However, growing evidence suggests that floodplains frequently fail to deliver these functions under conditions of climatic intensification and complex socio-spatial constraints. This paper examines why floodplains fail in practice and what consequences this failure has for flood hazard and risk, using a comparative case study of Carlisle (UK) and New Orleans (USA). Drawing on historical flood events, spatial development trajectories, and management practices, the analysis shows that floodplain failure is not merely a technical limitation but a systemic process that amplifies flood hazard, exposure, and vulnerability. In both cities, floodplains have been progressively constrained, fragmented, or functionally disconnected from river dynamics, reducing their capacity to buffer extreme floods and increasing residual and systemic risk. While the two cases differ in institutional context and management pathways, they converge in similar risk outcomes under extreme flooding. The findings highlight floodplain failure as a critical yet underexplored mechanism of flood risk formation and underscore the limits of floodplain-based management as a standalone strategy for risk reduction under escalating climatic extremes.
In real life, psychological and physiological states rarely change along a single dimension. Through self-tracking and discussions with clinicians, I have come to recognise with increasing clarity that sleep patterns, autonomic arousal, bodily sensations, and cognitive load are in constant interaction. Existing models often fail to capture this complexity. Many theoretical frameworks continue to analyse these elements in isolation, making it difficult to explain sudden changes reported by individuals,such as abrupt spikes in anxiety, sudden drops in dissociation, or even moments of heightened alertness. The mathematical modelling employed herein does not replace clinical or subjective narratives, but rather provides a structural framework for these rapid transitions and elucidates why bodily-driven and cognitively-driven changes manifest differently. The objective is to build a conceptual bridge between physiological signals and lived experience, laying the groundwork for dynamic modelling and future case analyses.
Flood risk management research increasingly recognises that technical and institutional solutions alone are insufficient to reduce flood impacts under accelerating climate change. While comparative studies have examined governance structures and policy instruments, considerably less attention has been paid to how regional cultures shape citizen participation and, in turn, influence policy effectiveness. This literature review addresses this gap by examining how cultural mechanisms mediate flood governance outcomes in Central Europe and China, with particular attention to the Rhine and Yellow River Basins.Drawing on interdisciplinary literature spanning flood governance, cultural geography, disaster studies, and public participation, the review demonstrates that flood policies operate through culturally embedded interpretations of risk, responsibility, and authority. In Central Europe, traditions of local self-organisation and participatory governance support bottom-up engagement in flood preparedness and risk-sharing. In contrast, long-standing state-centred flood cultures in China have fostered strong reliance on structural protection and administrative control, while limiting autonomous civic participation.By reframing culture as an active policy mechanism rather than a passive contextual factor, this review highlights why flood management strategies with similar technical rationales generate divergent participation patterns and resilience outcomes across regions. The findings suggest that culturally insensitive policy designs risk underperforming, even when engineering capacity is high. The article concludes by outlining implications for flood governance, arguing that integrating cultural mechanisms into policy formulation is essential for enhancing public engagement, legitimacy, and long-term flood resilience.
Climate change has intensified the frequency and severity of extreme flooding events, challenging the effectiveness of conventional urban flood management strategies. Floodplains are increasingly promoted as nature-based solutions for flood risk reduction; however, their performance under extreme and compound flooding conditions remains context-dependent and insufficiently understood. This study examines the role and limitations of floodplain-based flood management through a qualitative comparative case study of two flood-prone cities: New Orleans (USA) and Carlisle (UK). Despite substantial differences in geomorphology, governance systems, and socioeconomic contexts, both cities experienced severe flood events that exposed the failure of floodplains and engineered defences to provide adequate protection under extreme climatic stress. Drawing on document analysis and secondary data, the comparison identifies four interacting factors shaping floodplain performance: environmental constraints, urban development patterns, governance capacity, and civic participation. The findings show that floodplains alone cannot function as reliable flood risk reduction measures when ecological degradation, land-use pressures, and institutional fragmentation undermine their buffering capacity. Rather than serving as substitutes for structural defences, floodplains operate most effectively as complementary components within integrated flood risk management frameworks that combine ecological restoration, spatial planning, and inclusive governance. This study contributes empirical insights into the context-specific applicability of floodplain strategies and highlights the importance of adaptive, place-based governance for urban disaster risk reduction under climate change.