Generative AI presents a profound challenge to the existing structures and purposes of education. It forces us to reconsider not only how we teach and learn but also, more fundamentally, what education is for. This conceptual paper argues that, in order to integrate AI into education in a way that can meet the major challenges facing humanity, ranging from ecological crisis to the future of democratic societies, we must reframe education. Drawing on the nature and potential of generative AI in conjunction with educational theory, we propose a double dialogic pedagogy that recognises education as both teaching thinking through dialogue and inducting students into participation in the long‐term powerful dialogues of culture. We relate this double dialogic pedagogy with AI to education for collective intelligence. This pedagogy positions AI not as a replacement for human thinking, but as a partner in expanding the space of dialogue. By articulating this theoretical foundation, we offer a basis for the future design of educational practices and technologies that can support human flourishing in an age of accelerating technological change. Practitioner notes: What is already known about this topic The rise of generative AI, particularly large language models, poses both opportunities and challenges for education. While existing research highlights AI's potential to support personalised learning through intelligent tutoring systems, concerns remain about its possible negative impact on students' critical and creative thinking. Previous studies have also noted the need for educational theory to keep pace with technological developments, yet little work has been done to articulate a pedagogical framework that addresses the broader societal and environmental challenges of the AI era. What this paper adds This paper proposes a double dialogic pedagogy as a theoretical foundation for integrating AI into educational design. It situates current developments in AI within a historical and philosophical context, drawing on dialogic theory and the concept of the pharmakon to argue that AI is neither inherently beneficial nor harmful, but depends on pedagogical framing. The paper advances the field by explicitly linking AI‐supported learning to education for collective intelligence, offering concrete illustrations of how AI can support both dialogic learning and induction into long‐term cultural dialogues. Implications for practice and/or policy This paper suggests that educational practice should shift from focusing on individual knowledge acquisition towards cultivating collective intelligence through dialogic pedagogy. Policymakers and educators are encouraged to design AI‐supported learning environments that promote collaborative problem‐solving and critical engagement with real‐world challenges, such as those posed by the Anthropocene. Assessment policies should be re‐evaluated to reward collaborative inquiry and ethical reasoning, rather than individual content reproduction. This reconceptualisation positions education as a key enabler of planetary‐level self‐regulation and human flourishing in the face of technological and environmental disruptions.
23 December 2024 in International Journal of Artificial Intelligence in Education
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is increasingly being used in education, but mostly to support individual teaching and learning. However, there are good reasons to think that thinking together and solving problems together, Collective Intelligence (CI), is also a valuable outcome of education. Accordingly, our main research question is: How can AI be used effectively to support education for CI? We address this question by means of a literature review and a conceptual analysis in response to the findings of that review. This leads us to propose a three-part framework for thinking about how AI can be used to support education for CI: (i) aiding group formation and composition, (ii) prompting the more effective staging of CI projects, and (iii) improving the process of joint thinking and collaborative problem solving. These three dimensions can be addressed at various levels, from small groups to large collaborations, and in two distinct modes, AI as environment or AI as agent. We conclude the paper with a call for more design-based research of AI, CI and education, building on our proposed framework, developing effective ways to educate students for Collective Intelligence.
Serendipity is at the heart of innovative ideas and strategic opportunities and is crucial for business success. Cultivating serendipity has become a growing priority for many organizations, typically by redesigning work environments and introducing aligned incentive schemes. These strategies, however, often fail to deliver the expected results. Given this, we propose leveraging GenAI-enabled dialogic training as an alternative. In this new paradigm, GenAI supports individuals in engaging in dialogue that creates psychologically safe space for them to co-evolve with diverse and unknown ideas. By engaging in the dialogic space, individuals develop the skillsets to question assumptions, challenge preconceptions, and critically assess new ideas, all of these are also core for developing a serendipitous mindset that enables individuals and corporates be ready to recognize, embrace, and harness serendipity effectively and sustainably.