In this commentary, we describe the English language placement adaptations we were required to make due to the world-wide COVID-19 pandemic. It includes a brief description of our placement test battery which was adapted to address our institution's move to a remote teaching/learning mode. A discussion of the major challenges we experienced, their impacts, and how we addressed them is also included. Finally, we discuss what we have learned about the processes and how we will make further adaptations in future placement test administrations using a virtual platform.
ESL writing teachers face the challenge of providing written feedback that is both effective and motivating to students. Thus, many end up making use of praise (or positive feedback) before offering criticism. Only limited research has examined how students perceive praise, and few studies among the most recent have focused on praise above other types of feedback. Moreover, researchers have not accounted for the effect of person-focused vs. performance-focused praise. We developed an original survey to understand how L2 learners perceive and value person and performance praise in written feedback. A total of 106 adult participants from two language groups (Asian and Romance) and at two English ability levels (intermediate and advanced) rated six different samples of praise based on how clear, helpful, valuable, encouraging to revision, kind, and motivating they found praise comments to be. Ultimately, praise type appeared to be the most significant variable as participants showed preference to performance over person praise. These results can be useful for teachers as they consider how to word statements of praise, particularly in response to student writing.
1 February 2025 in Teaching English as a Second or Foreign Language--TESL-EJ
Students are often encouraged to proofread their writing by reading it aloud. Presumably, this will allow writers to correct local errors. Yet even though this strategy may be effective for native speakers, there is little empirical evidence of its benefit among second language writers. Therefore, we wondered how many errors second language students could correct through reading aloud and how that compared when receiving teacher feedback. In this study, 60 ESL students composed four in-class, 10-minute essays over two weeks. Half of the students revised their essays after receiving teacher feedback; the other half revised after reading aloud. All errors on initial and revised essays were tallied and normalized. Results showed that reading aloud affected some surface errors but that teacher feedback significantly outperformed reading aloud. We recommend teachers use reading aloud as a supplementary or preliminary strategy for correcting surface errors but not as a replacement for expert feedback provision.
While ESL writing teachers often deal with a heavy feedback workload on student writing, training students to self-assess their own work can ease the burden and empower students, especially if self-assessment increases self-efficacy and self-regulation. A self-assessment method is rubric training where teachers guide students in reading and grading sample essays. This research explores whether rubric training leads to positive emotional and regulatory gains. Twenty-one multilingual writers enrolled in a first-year writing class received incremental, short-term exposure to rubric training during which established self-efficacy and self-regulated learning scales were administered three times. Scores were compared to 15 writers in a control group, where students completed the same questionnaires on the same class days but received no rubric training. Results showed rubric training had a significant impact on students’ self-efficacy but not self-regulation. In post-assessment interviews, most students expressed feeling positive about rubric training because of the model essays. Some did not like the rubric because they thought it was difficult to read. A lexical analysis of the rubric showed it was likely beyond students’ reading level. Still, self-efficacy bridges students’ self-assessment and language gains; therefore, rubric training may be a useful tool when teachers use it to increase students’ self-efficacy.
12 November 2026 in Current Issues in Language Planning