Background: Tidal volume (VT) during mechanical ventilation in dogs varies considerably between individuals, but the contributions of airway dead space (VDaw) and alveolar tidal volume (VTalv) to this variability remain unclear. Methods: In this prospective, observational, exploratory study, 95 anesthetized dogs receiving volume-controlled ventilation with VT initially set at 15 mL kg⁻¹ of predicted ideal body weight (IBW) were analyzed. When necessary, TV was titrated within a predetermined quasi-static driving pressure range (i.e., >6 and <10 cmH₂O) to maintain normocapnia. Volumetric capnography was used to measure expired tidal volume (VTe), VDaw, and VTalv. The relative contributions of VDaw and VTalv to VTe variability were assessed across body sizes and breeds, including brachycephalic dogs. In addition, the effects of ideal body weight (IBW) on the variability of VTe, VDaw, and VTalv were evaluated. Results: VTalv accounted for a greater proportion of the observed VTe variability than VDaw, indicating that interindividual differences in VTalv were the primary determinant of VT variability. Brachycephalic dogs exhibited smaller VDaw but similar VTalv compared with non-brachycephalic dogs. Ideal body weight was correlated with proportionally higher VDaw and lower VTalv. Recumbency was not correlated with the observed variability in VT components. Conclusions: VTalv was the main determinant of VT variability among anesthetized dogs, and the brachycephalic breeds studied exhibited smaller VDaw but similar VTalv compared with non-brachycephalic breeds. These findings highlight the importance of considering VTalv and breed-specific airway anatomy when individualizing ventilatory settings.