Automated driving vehicles will allow all occupants to spend their time with various non-driving related tasks like relaxing, working, or reading during the journey. However, a significant percentage of people is susceptible to motion sickness, which limits the comfort of engaging in those tasks during automated driving. Therefore, it is necessary to investigate the phenomenon of motion sickness during automated driving and to develop countermeasures. As most existing studies concerning motion sickness are fundamental research studies, a methodology for driving studies is yet missing. This paper discusses methodological aspects for investigating motion sickness in the context of driving including measurement tools, test environments, sample, and ethical restrictions. Additionally, methodological considerations guided by different underlying research questions and hypotheses are provided. Selected results from own studies concerning motion sickness during automated driving which were conducted in a motion-based driving simulation and a real vehicle are used to support the discussion.
The introduction of automated-driving functions provides passengers with the opportunity to engage in non-driving related tasks during the ride. However, this benefit might be compromised by an increased incidence of motion sickness. Therefore, we investigated the effectiveness of active seat belt retractions as a countermeasure against motion sickness during inattentive automated driving. We hypothesized that seat belt retractions would mitigate motion sickness by supporting passengers to anticipate upcoming braking maneuvers, by actively tensioning their neck muscles and, thereby, reducing the extent of forward head movement while braking. In a motion base driving simulator, 26 participants encountered two 30 min automated drives in slow-moving traffic: one drive with active seat belt retractions before each braking maneuver and a baseline drive without. The results revealed that there was no difference in perceived motion sickness between both experimental conditions. Seat belt retractions resulted in an increased activity of the lateral neck muscles and supported drivers to anticipate braking maneuvers. However, at the same time, the retractions led to an increased magnitude of head movement in response to braking. This research lays the groundwork for future research on active seat belt retractions as a countermeasure against motion sickness and provides directions for future work.
Sleep inertia is the post-awakening transitional state of lowered arousal, characterized by increased low-frequency activity in the electroencephalogram (EEG) and impaired cognition. While some theories consider arousal holistically, recent research questions whether these findings apply to situations requiring immediate critical action post-awakening, such as for pilots, emergency responders, or future drivers of automated vehicles. This study compared self-reported, cortical, and physiological arousal in such a scenario. Twenty-four participants completed four drives in a driving simulator. In three drives, participants were instructed to sleep for 20, 40, and 60 min during automated driving before being prompted to resume control. The sleep stage prior to the takeover request served as a quasi-experimental independent variable. Regression analyses showed that cortical arousal was low following awakenings from N2 or N3, indicated by increased delta, theta, and alpha activity. However, beta activity and heart rate also increased, suggesting elevated physiological arousal. Significant positive correlations were found between delta activity, heart rate and self-reported sleepiness. This “arousal paradox” is not in line with the idea of arousal as a holistic concept. We hypothesize that the heightened physiological response under sleep inertia may be attributed to stress in demanding situations under sleep inertia. We conclude that forced awakenings from N2 or N3 should be avoided. If someone is nevertheless awakened from N2 or N3, they should be given sufficient time between awakening and taking over duties for arousal to normalize.