Climate change-exacerbated flooding has renewed interest in property buyouts as a pillar of managed retreat from coastal zones and floodplains in the United States. However, federal buyout programs are widely critiqued for being inaccessible and inequitable. To learn whether and how subnational buyout programs overcome these limitations, we examined five leading US state, county, and local buyout programs to see what they teach us about redesigning future federal policies. Our mixed-methods research used interviews and document analysis to develop case studies, juxtaposed subnational strategies against a review of critiques of federal buyouts, and focus group discussions with subnational buyout managers and experts to identify limitations of their programs. We find that subnational programs can be more inclusive and better respond to resident needs as compared to existing federal programs due to their access to dedicated, non-federal funding and their standing institutional status, which allows them to learn and evolve over time. Nevertheless, these programs lack coordination with and control over agencies that permit development and produce affordable housing. This gives buyout programs limited power in shaping the overall equity of who lives in floodplains and who has access to affordable, resilient housing after a buyout. Their experiences suggest federal programs can support managed retreat nationwide by increasing support for institutional and staff capacity at state and county levels, encouraging efforts to bridge institutional silos at subnational levels, and holistically mainstream climate considerations into regional floodplain development, affordable housing production, and flood risk mitigation.
How can gender and empowerment drive the development of a community’s adaptive capacity to disasters? Disaster plans can be used to allocate resources, instill processes, and reach goals; however, once in place, these plans can also be a determining factor to either empower or exclude. One of the 17 United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), SDG 5, targets gender equality and empowerment for all women and girls. Under the lens of SDG 5, working toward this goal of equality and empowerment as part of disaster preparedness will improve the capacity of a community to respond and recover, ultimately reducing vulnerability for everyone. Intentionally building disaster management plans toward gender equality can be one of the key strategies that improves community resilience for all. In order to identify challenges and opportunities linking policy and practice, this paper shares a case study of disaster planning in Peru to understand mitigation strategies and explore gender equality as a tool to expand adaptive capacity.
In the United States, most floodplain relocation (or buyout) programs focus on moving homeowners, then deal separately with what happens with the land afterward. These programs typically divide processes for relocation planning, engagement, funding, and implementation from those related to post-buyout land management and restoration. The structural and operational conditions that lead to this separation of roles and responsibilities miss out on opportunities to create more synergistic socio-ecological strategies that may produce healthier outcomes for both people and the environment. In other domains, research shows that healthy people and healthy environments can co-create each other through more virtuous cycles. In this perspective essay, we argue that we can better create such virtuous cycles in floodplain relocation programs by integrally considering social and ecological components. Such efforts can encourage more people to decide to relocate, thereby creating more contiguous places to restore. They can also empower more residents to help steward these sites, an action that in turn helps heal and strengthen flood-affected communities. These arguments, while particular to the United States, have resonance for floodplain management and land use planning worldwide.
The disciplinary identity of the field of emergency management is inherently interconnected; it is difficult to recognize which discipline is prominent when unraveling complex problems with cascading effects. However, the structure of institutions of higher education (IHE) traditionally resists integrating academic fields because faculty members specialize in one subject area for teaching and research. That is not how disasters work; disasters are complex and affect communities in various ways; thus there is a need for multiple disciplines to collaborate on building effective solutions. A service-learning project can be an opportunity to bridge disciplines within IHE and translate them into practice. The terms multidisciplinary, interdisciplinary, and transdisciplinary (MITD) are often used interchangeably, but they are different in context and application. This chapter discusses the framing of partnerships to solve complex problems that provide opportunities to move beyond the silo mentality by engaging students in MITD service-learning projects and activities, making communities safer, and being more responsive to their particular needs.
When collecting data for academic research or as part of a service-learning activity in an emergency setting, it is important to carefully consider strategies for participant recruitment, data collection, and the community work to ensure all stages of the activity are completed ethically and appropriately. Failure to consider the ethics of the intended work, specifically involving people affected by a disaster, can harm both the community and the quality of work. There are ethical issues involved with studying and working with human participants in any context; their well-being must always be considered and protected. Both disaster research and disaster-related service-learning projects will include participants who may already be distressed, traumatized, or coping with personal, financial, or professional losses. Further, disaster research and service-learning, compared to other fields, bring a unique and enhanced risk due to the “gold rush” whereby many hurry to carry out research and provide service as quickly as possible following emergencies. This “gold rush” can negatively impact the participants’ well-being caused by the reduction in quality of research and community service as a result of poor methodological designs, resulting in harming community trust and wasted research efforts. Increased planning, coordination, and reflection on reducing potential harm by researchers and service-learners can improve the quality of work and decrease the likelihood of causing research fatigue, distrust, or psychological harm in disaster-affected communities.
The purpose of this research is to identify how decision-makers within anchor institutions, using the context of higher education, determine the course of action in response to an improbable disaster event, such as the recent coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic. A survey was conducted among higher education decision-makers during spring 2020 at the moment they were adapting to COVID-19. The survey aimed to identify policies and planning measures that may help Institutions of Higher Education learn from this experience to maintain continuity of operations should similar or unanticipated events occur in the future. With this knowledge, both assets and detriments contributing to community vulnerability can be better balanced to inform decision-making. The outcomes of the analysis and shared reflections inform the development of future policy and strengthen existing processes for preparedness and mitigation planning for unexpected events.