Large-scale, in-lake enclosures (limnocorrals) were used to simulate spills of diluted bitumen (dilbit) in a boreal lake. In this study we use these simulated spills, which covered a range of sizes (oil:water ratio) representative of the upper 25% of onshore crude oil spills in North America (2008-2019), to assess the fate of dilbit-derived hydrocarbons and metals as well as the impacts of the spills on standard water quality parameters. The systems were monitored over 70 days following the application of dilbit amounts ranging between 1.5 and 179.8 L into 10-m diameter, ~100 m3 limnocorrals. The concentration of total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) in the water column increased rapidly over the first two weeks reaching a plateau that ranged between 200 μg/L and 2200 μg/L for the lowest and highest treatment respectively. The concentration of total polycyclic aromatic compounds (PACs) also increased over the first two weeks, prior to a slow decrease until day 70. The maximum measured concentrations in the highest treatment were 2858 ng/L for the sum of all 46 quantified PACs, 2716 ng/L for alkylated PACs and 154 ng/L for the 16 EPA priority PAHs. The concentrations of PACs in the sediment increased continuously over the study in the three highest treatments with maximum observed concentrations of 189 ng/g for ΣPAC46, 169 ng/g for ΣPACalk. No significant treatment-related changes in the 16 EPA priority PAHs were observed in the sediment. Of the 25 metals quantified in the water column, only manganese, molybdenum, and vanadium displayed a significant treatment effect with increases of 280, 76 and 25% respectively in the total fraction. These results can help us understand and predict the fate of oil-derived contaminants following a spill and characterize the exposure of freshwater organisms living within them. These results should help inform the risk assessment of future dilbit transportation projects.
2 September 2022 in Journal of Environmental Management
Canada is a top producer and exporter of crude oil but also has many in-land freshwater ecosystems that need protection using non-invasive remediation methods that are effective in sensitive environments. To assess the efficacy of enhanced monitored natural recovery (eMNR) as a secondary remediation strategy for freshwater oil spills, we conducted controlled spills of conventional heavy crude oil (CHV) in a freshwater lake at the IISD-Experimental Lakes Area in northwestern Ontario, Canada, in 2021. Three shoreline enclosures (5 × 10 m) were deployed on a wetland shoreline and treated with ~1.5 kg of weathered CHV. Four days later primary recovery of oil was conducted using shoreline washing followed by secondary remediation of residual oil using eMNR. Three unoiled, reference enclosures were also treated with shoreline washing but not secondary remediation. Polycyclic aromatic compounds (PAC) in water and sediment, and general water quality were monitored in the enclosures for 412 days after oiling. Total PACs in the water, mostly of 2- and 3-ring alkylated compounds, peaked three days after oiling (1188 ± 251 ng/L), declined to half of initial concentrations 8.26–11.75 days later and to near background levels by day 73. Total PACs were elevated in sediment of the oiled enclosures until day 70 likely due to sorption or settling oil but were heterogenous and influenced by pyrogenic compounds. Results from this study suggest that eMNR may be an effective remediation method following primary recovery efforts at sensitive aquatic sites where mechanical recovery is contraindicated.
The efficacy of oil spill response depends on the speed of detecting the oil. Detecting submerged oil is more difficult than oil on the water surface, because most conventional sensors are not effective. Oil Detection Canines (ODCs) have been reliably used to detect oil during shoreline spill surveys, and preliminary laboratory studies also showed promising results for detecting oil submerged under water. To confirm their potential, a field study was conducted in a boreal freshwater lake in Northwestern Ontario, Canada to investigate the capability of an ODC to detect submerged weathered oils at depths of 1 to 5 m. Triplicate targets at each depth used weathered diluted bitumen (dilbit), Bunker C residual fuel oil, and Maya crude oil burn residue and both the ODC and handler blinded to the location of each target. Boat-based searches were conducted and the handler identified “alerts” based on ODC behaviour changes that were compared to georeferenced oil target locations. The ODC positively identified seven (7) of the eight (8) dilbit targets at 1 to 5 m, five (5) of the six (6) Bunker C targets at 1 and 3 m, and none of the burn residue targets at 1-m depth. The ability of ODCs to detect submerged or sunken oil in shallow water was clearly demonstrated, adding another technique for submerged and sunken oil surveys with the advantages of real-time data returns, the ability to detect small oil deposits, and an operational capability in shallow waters with potential for detection in deeper water.