We revisit Weyl’s unified field theory, which arose in 1918, shortly after general relativity was discovered. As is well known, in order to extend the program of geometrization of physics started by Einstein to include the electromagnetic field, H. Weyl developed a new geometry which constitutes a kind of generalization of Riemannian geometry. However, despite its mathematical elegance and beauty, a serious objection was made by Einstein, who considered Weyl’s theory not suitable as a physical theory since it seemed to lead to the prediction of a not yet observed effect, the so-called “second clock effect”. In this paper, our aim is to discuss Weyl’s proposal anew and examine its consistency and completeness as a physical theory. Finally, we propose new directions and possible conceptual changes in the original work. As an application, we solve the field equations assuming a Friedmann-Robertson-Walker universe and a perfect fluid as its source. Although we have entirely abandoned Weyl’s attempt to identify the vector field with the 4-dimensional electromagnetic potentials, which here must be simply viewed as part of the space-time geometry, we believe that in this way we could perhaps be led to a rich and interesting new modified gravity theory.
We present a detailed study on the geometrization of the Proca field in the so-called Weyl Gauge-Invariant Theory, shedding new light on the physical interpretation of the Weyl field. We first describe the field equations of the theory. We then obtain a solution for the weak field using a spherically symmetric and static approximate metric. Our analysis revealed that the Weyl field, in the weak field approximation, exhibits a behavior identical to the Yukawa potential, similar to the Proca field. Furthermore, the obtained metric solution is equivalent to the Einstein–Proca case, demonstrating that the description of the Weyl field in the Weyl Gauge-Invariant Theory is consistent with Proca theory in the context of General Relativity. Finally, we conclude that the Weyl field can be formally interpreted as a Proca field of geometrical nature.
We revisit Weyl's unified field theory, which arose in 1918, shortly after general relativity was discovered. As is well known, in order to extend the program of geometrization of physics started by Einstein to include the electromagnetic field, H. Weyl developed a new geometry which constitutes a kind of generalization of Riemannian geometry. However, despite its mathematical elegance and beauty, a serious objection was made by Einstein, who considered Weyl's theory not suitable as a physical theory since it seemed to lead to the prediction of a not yet observed effect, the so-called "second clock effect" . In this paper, our aim is to discuss Weyl's proposal anew and examine its consistency and completeness as a physical theory. Finally, we propose new directions and possible conceptual changes in the original work. As an application, we solve the field equations assuming a Friedmann-Robertson-Walker universe and a perfect fluid as its source. Although we have entirely abandoned Weyl's atempt to identify the vector field with the 4-dimensional electromagnetic potentials, which here must be simply viewed as part of the space-time geometry, we believe that in this way we could perhaps be led to a rich and interesting new modified gravity theory.
We present a detailed study of the geometrization of the Proca field in the so-called Weyl Invariant Theory, shedding new light on the physical interpretation of the Weyl field. We first describe the field equations of the theory. We then obtain a solution for the weak field using a spherically symmetric and static approximate metric. Our analysis revealed that the Weyl field, in the weak field approximation, exhibits a behaviour identical to the Yukawa potential, similar to the Proca field. Furthermore, the obtained metric solution is equivalent to the Einstein-Proca case, demonstrating that the description of the Weyl field in the Weyl Invariant Theory is consistent with Proca theory in the context of General Relativity. Finally, we conclude that the Weyl field can be formally interpreted as a Proca field of geometrical nature.