Transcriptomic similarity is used to characterize disease models, but a comparison can change when the same responses are summarized differently. We examined mean-centering before pathway averaging in 16 disease states from one feline chronic kidney disease cohort and two mouse kidney injury models, using 2016 genes detected in both species’ proteomes and 422 overlapping pathways. Among 87 state pairs without shared control samples, uncentered pathway means separated same-species from cross-species pairs with an area under the curve of 0.868; removing each state’s mean across genes first reduced this to 0.511. The uncentered value was higher in 98.6% of animal-level resamples, and the difference held across nine offset and filter settings, all four gene spaces and the 83-pair subset without shared animals. Under within-state ranking or quantile normalization, which equalize each state’s overall level by construction, the contrast fell to 0.010 and 0.001. Reference-axis projections can rank states differently from cosine because they retain amplitude, and benchmark gaps were poorly calibrated. These results identify a consequential preprocessing choice rather than a preferred species or a validated measure of disease fidelity. Because all feline states came from one cohort and all mouse states from two datasets, species was confounded with dataset throughout, and the separation reported here may reflect dataset-specific technical variation rather than species biology.
Low nephron endowment is associated with hypertension and chronic kidney disease. We compared recovered glomerular counts and kidney mass across four mouse strains at 8 weeks of age and examined age-associated phenotypes and developmental kidney transcriptomes in FVB/N and C57BL/6J mice. Sex-adjusted models allowing for strain-specific variances showed lower recovered counts and counts per gram of kidney in FVB/N than in the other strains. Proportional scaling with kidney mass was not supported. After adjustment for kidney weight, differences remained significant relative to BALB/c and DBA/2, whereas the difference from C57BL/6J remained unresolved. These measurements do not establish absolute nephron endowment. In independent groups of males of different ages, FVB/N mice showed greater glomerular enlargement and higher semiquantitative urinary albumin-to-creatinine ratios. Strain-matched developmental RNA-seq attenuated measurable reference-genome effects. Deconvolution using either the P1 or E14.5 single-cell reference detected no strain difference in the estimated progenitor proportion at E13.5, although absolute estimates were reference-dependent. No coordinated GDNF–RET downregulation or significant kidney-related enrichment was detected. Integration of regulatory annotations prioritised five genes as exploratory candidates. Lower interferon-related expression in FVB/N at P1 was consistent across samples and leave-one-out analyses. Developmental phenotyping and independent genetic validation are needed to establish the origins of these strain differences.
Genomic instability caused by defective DNA double-strand break (DSB) repair is a key determinant of cellular radiosensitivity. The Long–Evans cinnamon (LEC) rat is a rare naturally occurring model with marked radiosensitivity, and a major quantitative trait locus, X-ray hypersensitivity 1 (xhs1), has been mapped to rat chromosome 4; however, the causal mechanism has remained unclear. Here, we investigated the cellular and molecular basis of xhs1-associated radiosensitivity using LEA and LEC rat-derived cells and human cultured cells. Exploratory RNA-seq of pre-hepatitic liver tissue identified a sequence variant within the Hmces transcript in LEC rats. Consistently, HMCES protein levels were markedly reduced in multiple tissues and liver-derived cell lines from LEC rats. Functional analyses showed that reduced HMCES activity prolonged γH2AX signaling after X-ray irradiation, indicating delayed DSB resolution. Clonogenic survival assays demonstrated increased radiosensitivity in HMCES-deficient cells, which was partially rescued by restoring HMCES expression in stable LEA/LEC lines. Moreover, pimEJ5GFP reporter assays revealed significantly decreased end-joining repair activity in HMCES-knockout human cells. Together, these results establish HMCES as a critical mediator of DSB repair and cellular radioresistance, identify HMCES dysfunction as a core genetic determinant underlying xhs1-associated radiosensitivity, and provide mechanistic insight into radiation response architecture in a naturally occurring radiosensitive model.