Organized activity involvement contributes to social cohesion and individual development, yet substantial socioeconomic disparities persist. Although prior research shows that both genetic differences and family socioeconomic status (SES) shape organized activity involvement, less is known about how socioeconomic contexts condition the realization of genetic potential. Drawing on gene–environment interaction theory, this study examines whether family SES amplifies or attenuates genetic influences on organized activity involvement. We contrast two competing perspectives: the High-SES Amplification model, which predicts stronger genetic influences in advantaged contexts, and the Low-SES Expression model, which predicts stronger genetic influences in disadvantaged contexts. Using data from the German Twin Family Panel (TwinLife, ages 4–25, N = 7,973), we estimate classical twin models that decompose variance in organized activity involvement into additive genetic, shared environmental, and non-shared environmental components and test whether these components vary across SES levels. Results show that genetic influences are stronger at higher levels of family SES, supporting the High-SES Amplification hypothesis and highlighting how family SES shapes inequality in organized activity involvement by moderating the realization of genetic potential.