This paper evaluates the data quality of road axes using the OpenStreetMap (OSM) collaborative mapping platform. OSM was chosen owing to the abundance of data and registered contributors (~ 6 million). We assumed the OSM collaborative data could complement the reference mappings by its quality parameters. We used the cartographic quality indicators of positional accuracy, thematic accuracy, and completeness to validate vector files from OSM. We analyzed the positional accuracy of linear features and we developed the automation of the positional accuracy process. The tool verified the completeness of road axes and thematic accuracy. The positional accuracy of linear features was also used, performed to obtain a range of scales, which reflected the characteristics of mapped areas and varied from 1:22,500 to 1:25,000. The completeness of road axes was 82% of the checked areas. By evaluating the thematic accuracy, we found that the absence of road axes toponymy in editions caused errors in the OSM features (i.e., 58% of road axes without information). As such, we concluded that collaborative data complements the reference cartography by measuring the heterogeneity of information in various regions and filtering the OSM data, despite its being useful for certain analyses.
The potential of intrinsic parameters to estimate geospatial data quality on Voluntary Geographic Information (VGI) platforms is a recurrent theme in Cartography. The spatial-temporal distribution in these platforms is very heterogeneous, depending on several factors such as input availability, number, and motivation of volunteers, especially in developing countries. The most recent approaches have been aiming to detail temporal patterns as an additional measure of quality in VGI. This research proposes a methodology to identify and analyze the behavior of the contribution parameters over time (2007-2022) of the OSM platform and differentiates the influences that affect its growth. Part of the Metropolitan region of Curitiba was the study area, subdivided into 1 x 1 km cells. The cumulative growth of contributions was calculated and later adjusted using a Logistic Regression. The obtained parameters made it possible to identify abruptly growing cells caused by external data import, mass contributions, or collective mapping activities. In addition, heterogeneity in the growth of the data available in OSM over time was evident. Furthermore, the proposed methodology promoted the investigation of a new indicator of intrinsic quality based on modelling the spatiotemporal evolution of OSM feature insertions.
This paper presents the development of a QGIS plugin to support evaluating the planimetric positional quality for point and linear features based on the metrics established by Brazilian legislation. For this purpose, we used the QGIS environment Graphical Modeler, which consists of an interface to concatenate a series of processes into a single algorithm. The set of tools, called QPEC, allows for performing the statistical tests from the automatic identification of the sample size and discrepancies. In order to demonstrate the implemented functionalities, a case study was carried out. In this illustrative example, the vector files from the Cartographic and Cadastral System of the Municipality of Salvador - BA (SICAD) were the reference data, and their homologous OpenStreetMap (OSM) features were the analysed database. The results obtained are presented in the attributes table. In addition, the spatial distribution of the discrepancies is visualised through the visual variable colour value in a quartile classification. The creation of this toolset corroborates the feasibility of developing more visual, automated and complete interfaces to support users of geospatial data in analysing the quality of the information available, especially when it involves free applications with open-source code.
Este artigo estima a heterogeneidade da acurácia posicional da rede viária do OpenStreetMap (OSM) no município do Rio de Janeiro, destacando implicações para análises de transportes e gestão ambiental urbana. A aplicação do Padrão de Exatidão Cartográfica em seis amostras independentes demonstrou, de forma estatisticamente significativa, que a qualidade do OSM não é homogênea, variando entre as classes B e C na escala 1:10.000. Os maiores erros posicionais, de até 9,07m, ocorreram em áreas formais consolidadas, indicando que a heterogeneidade é multifatorial e associada à defasagem temporal entre bases cartográficas, com impactos diretos em aplicações ambientais e de mobilidade.