Jane McCarthy

Prof. Jane McCarthy


Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

33Years (1994-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 January 1998
Verified
Book
Closed access
JMJane McCarthy
Jane McCarthy
RERosalind Edwards
Rosalind Edwards
How can researchers produce work with relevance to theoretical and formal traditions and requirements of public academic knowledge while still remaining fait

1 February 2012 in The Sociological Review
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JMJane McCarthy
Jane McCarthy

1 January 2011
Verified
Book
Closed access
JMJane McCarthy
Jane McCarthy
Rosalind EdwardsRosalind Edwards
Rosalind Edwards
Relevant, focused and accessible this book will provide students with an indispensible guide to the central concepts of family studies.

14 December 2012 in The British Journal of Sociology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
Rosalind EdwardsRosalind Edwards
Rosalind Edwards
JMJane McCarthy
Jane McCarthy
VGVal Gillies
Val Gillies

1 January 2003 in International Journal of Social Research Methodology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JMJane McCarthy
Jane McCarthy
JHJanet Holland
Janet Holland
VGVal Gillies
Val Gillies
The use of interviews from related individuals has become increasingly common in social research. This is particularly apparent in the area of family sociology, which has previously been criticized for relying on research of family lives based solely on interviews with mothers. Obtaining such accounts can raise postmodern ontological and epistemological themes of multiple perspectives and multiple realities, but there has been little explicit discussion of how to tackle the analysis of such related interviews. This paper explores approaches to the analysis of interviews with nine individuals drawn from three case study 'families'. An ideal typical categorization of possible approaches is developed, based on the cross-cutting themes of (1) degree of similarity/divergence, and (2) an objectivist/interpretationist ontology. The powerful role of the researcher's 'bird's eye view' is highlighted, involving the active interpretation of both disagreements and agreements between related interviews. A major feature of these approaches is the complexity of the data generated and the time involved in the analysis. Such analytic choices yield different forms of knowledge and lead us to 'see' varying patterns and themes according to the focus we take, whether we reveal the possibility of 'family cultures', the relevance of standpoint differences around gender and generation, or wider structural issues of class and ethnicity. Within individual accounts we can see how these different aspects are interwoven in particular histories. How we represent such complexities and tensions between related accounts is a further choice, which may depend upon the audience and purposes involved. Even where we choose to weave the threads into one apparently coherent overall story, we argue for openess and reflexivity concerning the difficult analytic choices that underlie such a production.

1 November 2000 in Sociology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JMJane McCarthy
Jane McCarthy
RERosalind Edwards
Rosalind Edwards
VGVal Gillies
Val Gillies
Family lives are an area where people's moral identities are crucially at stake. Yet the significance of dependent children to the work needed to sustain morally adequate adult identities is largely overlooked. Furthermore, the particular situation of divorce or separation and repartnering where children are involved is fundamentally relevant to current sociological debates about the changing nature of marriage and family life. Notions of the pursuit of self-development and couple intimacy clash and create tensions with notions of duty or responsibility to children's needs. Drawing on a study of parents and step-parents, we consider how interviewees' moral understandings were fundamentally shaped by social constructions of the Child and the Adult. Importantly, the presence of dependent children led to an overall key moral imperative concerning the requirement for responsible adults to put the needs of children first. There were, however, strong gender dimensions in the ways in which this moral imperative was played out, and in some tensions with an alternative, but secondary, moral ethic of care of self. We discuss the significance of the Child/Adult construction in relation to theories about the nature of contemporary family obligations and of contemporary morality more generally.