This article presents an exploratory study aimed at analyzing the instructional design of learning personalization practices in three secondary education centers that promote connections between students’ learning and/or their learning experiences in and out of school. We propose three dimensions for analysis, according to a constructivist and sociocultural perspective: the learning activities and contents designed to connect students’ learning and/or learning experiences across different contexts; the educational agents that enhance these connections; and the mediating tools used. Results indicate that our multidimensional model is useful for identifying the different didactic strategies that appear in each case to foster connections, and for detecting the aspects that need improvement. Conclusions suggest that in personalized learning environments, the focus of educational activity must be shifted from making connections between students’ learning to the learning experiences that students have at different times and in different contexts, helping them to build their personal learning pathways.
Technological tools have permeated higher education programs. However, their mere introduction does not guarantee instructional quality. This article presents the results of an innovation project aimed at fostering autonomous learning among students at a Pre-School and Primary Teacher Grade. For one semester all freshmen students used a system for autonomous learning embedded in the institutional online platform (Moodle), which included automatic formative feedback. The system was part of a complex formative assessment program. We present results of the experience concerning two aspects: the students’ actual use of the system, and their final appraisal of it. The quantitative descriptive analysis focuses on the students’ perspective to evaluate the adequacy of the instructional decisions. Results indicate that students need certain limits to be able to manage their learning better if we pursue the quality of innovation. These limits refer mainly to the time of accessibility and the limitation of attempts of practice. With respect to time, an appropriate span of time (neither too long nor too short) must be chosen; with respect to the number of attempts, it is expedient to limit rather than promote free endless access.Las herramientas tecnológicas han impregnado plenamente la educación superior. No obstante, el mero añadido no garantiza per se su calidad. Este artículo expone los resultados de un proyecto de innovación para fomentar el aprendizaje autónomo en los Grados de Educación Infantil y Primaria. Durante un semestre todos los alumnos de primer curso pudieron usar un sistema de aprendizaje autónomo en la plataforma online institucional (Moodle), apoyado con feedback formativo automático. El sistema se insertaba en un programa complejo de evaluación formativa. Se presentan resultados atendiendo a dos aspectos: uso real de los estudiantes y valoración final del sistema por parte de estos. El análisis cuantitativo descriptivo se centra en la perspectiva del estudiante para evaluar la adecuación de las decisiones pedagógicas tomadas. Los resultados indican que los estudiantes necesitan ciertos límites para poder organizar mejor su propio aprendizaje si queremos potenciar la calidad de la innovación planteada. Estos límites se concretan en variables tales como el tiempo de disponibilidad y la limitación de intentos de práctica. En el primer caso se debe atender a la duración adecuada de la oferta del sistema: tanto el exceso como el defecto de tiempo afectan a la cantidad y uso que realizan los estudiantes. En el segundo caso, la restricción de intentos es preferible a la práctica libre.
26 September 2014 in Innovations in Education and Teaching International
Collaborative writing is a task commonly used for learning and assessment in higher education. The complexity of this type of task requires special support for learning contents. Feedback can be used as a key element to improve students’ learning and engagement. This paper presents and evaluates a teaching innovation that sought to design a model feedback system. In this innovation, 218 students and 4 teachers participated in a course on Educational Psychology in Teacher Training. Questionnaires were used to collect students’ perceptions and their satisfaction ratings regarding the quality of feedback received from the teacher. The students’ uses of feedback were also taken into account. Additionally, interviews were conducted with instructors. The main results highlight the relevance of integrating the essential characteristics of effective feedback, as well as the use of ICT, for supporting learning in this complex task.
Esta investigación tuvo como objetivo caracterizar el feedback virtual ofrecido por el profesorado en contraste con las percepciones del alumnado. El estudio se desarrolló bajo un paradigma cualitativo y cuantitativo, y las personas participantes fueron dos profesoras de educación secundaria postobligatoria y sus discentes. Se realizó un análisis de contenido de las entrevistas y de los feedback, así como un análisis estadístico descriptivo de cuestionarios de satisfacción. Los resultados exponen la necesidad de atender a las características, intereses y necesidades del alumnado a la hora de planificar la entrega de feedback con uso de las tecnologías de la información y comunicación (TIC), lo cual influye en las percepciones y uso del feedback recibido.