Soil organic carbon (SOC) sequestration in agricultural soils is an important tool for climate change mitigation within the EU soil strategy for 2030 and can be achieved via the adoption of soil management strategies (SMS). These strategies may induce synergistic effects by simultaneously reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions and/or nitrogen (N) leaching. In contrast, other SMS may stimulate emissions of GHG such as nitrous oxide (N 2 O) or methane (CH 4 ), offsetting the climate change mitigation gained via SOC sequestration. Despite the importance of understanding trade‐offs and synergies for selecting sustainable SMS for European agriculture, knowledge on these effects remains limited. This review synthesizes existing knowledge, identifies knowledge gaps and provides research recommendations on trade‐offs and synergies between SOC sequestration or SOC accrual, non‐CO 2 GHG emissions and N leaching related to selected SMS. We investigated 87 peer‐reviewed articles that address SMS and categorized them under tillage management, cropping systems, water management and fertilization and organic matter (OM) inputs. SMS, such as conservation tillage, adapted crop rotations, adapted water management, OM inputs by cover crops (CC), organic amendments (OA) and biochar, contribute to increase SOC stocks and reduce N leaching. Adoption of leguminous CC or specific cropping systems and adapted water management tend to create trade‐offs by stimulating N 2 O emissions, while specific cropping systems or application of biochar can mitigate N 2 O emissions. The effect of crop residues on N 2 O emissions depends strongly on their C/N ratio. Organic agriculture and agroforestry clearly mitigate CH 4 emissions but the impact of other SMS requires additional study. More experimental research is needed to study the impact of both the pedoclimatic conditions and the long‐term dynamics of trade‐offs and synergies. Researchers should simultaneously assess the impact of (multiple) agricultural SMS on SOC stocks, GHG emissions and N leaching. This review provides guidance to policymakers as well as a framework to design field experiments and model simulations, which can address knowledge gaps and non‐intentional effects of applying agricultural SMS meant to increase SOC sequestration.
1 November 2023 in European Journal of Soil Science
Soil texture-dependent responses and time-scales of soil quality change, especially soil carbon, remain poorly understood. We addressed this gap using a dual time-scale design of long-term field experiments: 11 years of minimum (MT) versus ploughing tillage (CT), both followed by 5-year transitions to no-till (NT) in contrasting textures (loamy vs. silty clay) in NE Slovenia. In loamy soils, reduced tillage in the 0–10 cm layer increased soil organic carbon by 40–48%, dissolved organic carbon by 36–64%, permanganate oxidizable carbon by 67–84%, particulate organic carbon by 76–95%, and mineral-associated organic carbon (MAOC < 50 μm) by 28–34%. In silty clay soils, high clay content masked tillage effects, though labile pools showed stratification. MAOC < 20 μm remained stable across treatments and textures (2.0–2.5%), except under CT in loamy soil (1.73%), indicating enhanced decomposition. In loamy soils CT increased by 0.5–1 and 1–2 mm and decreased >20 mm and in silty clay soils increased <0.5, 1–2 and 2–4 mm aggregate formations. The MWD, GMD, Dm indices correlated strongly with C fractions, confirming physical protection mechanisms. Our dual time-scale approach reveals labile C pools and aggregate recovery respond within 5 years of NT, while texture modulates response magnitude and detectability.
Carbon losses from decomposition and erosion threaten intensive crop production systems. While conservation tillage enhances soil organic carbon (SOC), soil tex-ture-dependent responses and time-scales of soil quality change remain poorly understood. We addressed this gap using a dual time-scale design: 11 years of minimum tillage (MT) versus conventional ploughing (CT), followed by 5-year transitions to no-till (NT) in contrasting textures (loamy vs. silty clay) in NE Slovenia. In loamy soils, reduced tillage significantly increased SOC, dissolved organic carbon (DOC), permanganate oxidizable carbon (POX-C), particulate organic carbon (POC), and mineral-associated organic carbon (MAOC < 50 μm) in the 0-10 cm layer. In silty clay soils, high clay content provided baseline protection that masked tillage effects on bulk SOC, though POX-C and POC showed vertical stratification. MAOC in the fine fraction (< 20 μm) remained consistent (2.0-2.5%) across treatments and textures, except under CT in loamy soil (1.73%), indicating accelerated decomposition. Tillage intensity drove aggregate distribution: CT fragmented soil structure (fewer macroaggregates, higher Dm), while MT and NT promoted macroaggregate formation. Structural indices (MWD, GMD, Dm) correlated strongly with C fractions, confirming physical protection mechanisms. Our dual time-scale approach reveals labile C pools and aggregate recovery respond within 5 years of NT, while texture modulates response magnitude and detectability. Reducing tillage intensity consistently supports C preservation across textures, though lighter soils show faster, more pronounced responses.