Based on first-principles density functional theory, we investigated the relationship between the vibrational normal modes and the spectrum of the newest laboratory-prepared ice phase, an empty clathrate hydrate structure from gas hydrate named ice XVII. A 48-molecule supercell was designed to mimic the hydrogen-disordered structure. Despite its much lower density than ice Ih, its phonon density of states shows features very similar to those of that phase. In our previous studies of ice Ic and ice XIV, we found two basic hydrogen bond vibrational modes in these hydrogen-ordered ice phases, which contribute two sharp hydrogen bond peaks in the translation region. In this study, we found that this rule also holds in the hydrogen-disordered phase ice XVII. A water molecule vibrating along its angle bisector possesses strong energy, because this vibrational mode involves oscillation against four bonded neighbors. In contrast, a water molecule vibrating perpendicular to its angle bisector has low energy because this mode involves only two of the molecule’s hydrogen bonds. This is an evidence in hydrogen-disordered ice and strengthens our proposal that the existence of two basic hydrogen bond vibrational modes is a general rule among ice family.

It is always a difficult task to assign the peaks recorded from a vibrational spectrum. Herein, we explored a new pathway of density functional theory (DFT) simulation to present three kinds of spectra of ice XIV that can be referenced as inelastic neutron scattering (INS), infrared (IR), and Raman experimental spectrum. The INS spectrum is proportional to the phonon density of states (PDOS) while the photon scattering signals reflect the normal vibration frequencies near the Brillouin zone (BZ) center. Based on good agreements with the experimental data, we identified the relative frequency and made scientific assignments through normal vibration modes analysis. The two hydrogen bond (H-bond) peaks among the ice phases from INS were discussed and the dynamic process of the H-bond vibrations was found to be classified into two basic modes. We deduced that two H-bond modes are a general rule among the ice family and more studies are ongoing to investigate this subject.

Natural gas hydrates are ice-like crystalline materials formed from natural gas and clathrate ice under high pressure and low temperature. Ice XVI, the first S-II type clathrate ice produced in the lab, was simulated by first-principles density functional theory with the CASTEP code. A 34-molecule supercell was built to mimic the hydrogen-disordered structure. The vibrational spectra were calculated as a reference for inelastic neutron scattering (INS), infrared (IR) absorption, and Raman scattering experiments. Two kinds of H-bond vibration modes corresponding to two different bond strengths were found in our previous studies. In this paper, the statistics of distribution calculated by integrating these two kinds of modes was found to match the phonon density of states (PDOS) very well. We confirmed that the two basic types of H-bonds also appeared in clathrate ice XVI. The typical normal modes were analyzed to illustrate the dynamic process of lattice vibrations.

It is always difficult to assign the peaks of a vibrational spectrum in the far-infrared region. The two distinct peaks seen in many ice phases are still a mystery to date. The normal modes of ice XV were calculated using the CASTEP code based on first-principles density functional theory. On the basis of vibrational modes analysis, we divided the translational modes into three categories: four-bond vibrations, which have the highest energy levels; two-bond vibrations, which have medium levels of energy; and relative vibrations between two sublattices, which have the lowest energy. Whale et al. found that some intramolecular stretching modes include the isolated vibration of only one O–H bond, whereas the others do not vibrate in ice XV. We verified this phenomenon in this study and attributed it to local tetrahedral deformation. Analysis of normal modes, especially in the translation and stretching band of ice XV, clarified the physical insights of the vibrational spectrum and can be used with other ice phases.