Beer is an alcoholic beverage made primarily from malted cereals, water, hops, and yeast. Although barley is the most common cereal in brewing, corn malts are also used to produce beer in different countries. However, research on their production, physicochemical properties, and aging evolution is limited. In the present study, the evolution of various physicochemical features during the aging of six lager- and ale-fermented corn beers was investigated. Results after 18 months of aging showed decreases in most of the measured properties: total phenolics between 16 and 20%, antioxidant capacity between 17 and 23% by DPPH assay and 23–41% by ABTS assay, free anthocyanins between 38 and 55%, bitterness units between 32 and 42%, and SRM color and color intensity only dropped in lager beers, while in ale beers these properties increased. Finally, tonality increased in lager beers and one ale beer. This study enabled a more in-depth analysis of corn beer, focusing on the evolution of physicochemical properties during aging that are relevant to beer quality.