The growing miniaturization of electronic systems and the expansion of sustainable, autonomous IoT technologies emphasize the need for efficient, ultra-low-power energy harvesting devices. This study evaluates fifteen devices from five industry leaders for use in small-scale autonomous seed germination systems. Its novelty lies in applying a competitive profile matrix within a flexible multicriteria evaluation framework based on the simple additive weighting (SAW) method that uses a comprehensive set of competitive technology factors (CTFs). The results demonstrate that a transparent and structured methodology can generate prioritized lists of suitable energy harvesters while accounting for technical, economic, and environmental trade-offs. The study also shows that device rankings depend on the scope and objectives of the project. If these change, then the CTF selection, classification, and weighting adjust accordingly. Therefore, the relevance of this study lies in the adaptability, replicability, and audibility of the proposed framework, which supports the selection of informed technology for autonomous, IoT-based germination systems and other technological projects.
The ongoing miniaturization of electronic systems and the increasing demand for sustainable, autonomous technologies driven by the Internet of Things (IoT) highlight the importance of efficient, ultra-low-power energy harvesting devices. This study evaluates fifteen such devices manufactured by five of the eight industry leaders. The study assesses the technological suitability of these devices for small-scale, intelligent, autonomous seed germination systems. The evaluation is based on a flexible, practical, multicriteria analysis framework that incorporates a broad set of criteria related to the context of the case study system. The framework also considers the functional and operational limitations of the low-power energy harvesters under analysis. The findings suggest that a comprehensive and transparent methodological approach can generate a prioritized list of energy harvesters aligned with the case study system. This list facilitates selecting the most suitable energy harvesters for IoT-based, small-scale seed germination systems. The analysis demonstrates the feasibility of systematically and structurally selecting the analyzed energy harvesting devices while considering conflicting technical, economic, and environmental priorities. Finally, the study emphasizes that distinct device prioritization lists can emerge when the scope or objective of the project changes because these alterations impact the set of evaluation criteria, their ranking, and weighting. This study outlines a structured evaluation framework that can be adapted to different contexts to facilitate technology selection. Technology researchers and practitioners can use this replicable, auditable tool to identify the advantages and disadvantages of incorporating technology into specific projects.