In this study, 34 trials of formal formative assessment activities in the context of inquiry-based science education (IBSE) from Swiss primary and upper secondary school teachers will be analysed. The aim will be to explore the formal formative assessment activities implemented in IBSE at different school levels. The trials (14 from primary school, 20 from upper secondary school) are documented with teaching plans and teaching materials as well as with transcripts from individual interviews. For the analysis, the trials were coded with a deductively developed coding scheme involving categories specifying the inquiry characteristics of the trials as well as the formative assessment characteristics. Overall, the empirical results suggest that at primary school level, more extensive formative assessment practices are possible, such as the combination of several methods within the context of one inquiry unit. At upper secondary school level, formative assessment practices are more straightforward and closely linked to summative assessment practices. These differences will be used to develop characteristic features of formative assessment practices for the two school levels.
23 March 2025 in International Research in Geographical and Environmental Education
In the face of intensifying socio-ecological crises, there is a growing debate about how processes of societal transformation can be shaped. Education for Sustainable Development (ESD), particularly in its transformative orientation (ESD 3), is widely regarded as a key lever in this context. While ESD 3 gets increasingly differentiated in educational theory, its disciplinary grounding remains insufficiently specified. This article addresses this gap by examining which structural characteristics of sustainability issues must be exhibited to enable individual and societal transformation. Drawing on Integral Sustainability Science, sustainability-related transformation processes are differentiated along internal (the meaning-making and culture domain) and external dimensions (the behavior and systems domain), integrating both factual systemic interrelations and normative perspectives of meaning and interpretation. On this basis, sustainability issues are characterized by internal and external complexity as well as controversiality. These features are brought together in the 3C Framework for Sustainable Learning and extended by the dimension of individual and collective contingency. As societal transformation unfolds through social negotiation processes under conditions of (double) contingency, transformative education aims to foster a deeper understanding of sustainability issues and to enable learners to perceive themselves as part of societal transformation processes and to participate in collective negotiations under conditions of uncertainty.