Index insurance for forage, pasture, and rangeland has gained ground in policy and academic circles. Stakeholders promote it as an innovative risk management tool for enhancing resilience to drought-induced perils and providing a way for consumption smoothing to livestock producers in drought vulnerable ecosystems. Index insurance, which avoids market failures such as moral hazard, adverse selection, and transactional cost, has been piloted and implemented all over the world. To support future development and research on index-based insurance in livestock systems, operational index insurance for forage, pasture, and rangeland systems in developed (USA and Canada) and developing (Kenya and Ethiopia) countries are reviewed and compared. This paper finds some similar characteristics (huge subsidy payments—ranging from 50 to 100 percent, significant government role, low adoption, insufficient payouts, data challenges, etc.), of this product between the two regions. A major difference between the PRF and NDVI is the number of choices available to users of rainfall index insurance who face close to 3000 choice options, while NDVI users have less than 5 choice options available for them. Based on these insights, we highlight opportunities where the two regions can benchmark and improve upon their respective index insurance schemes—index-based livestock insurance (IBLI) in developing and rainfall index insurance for forage in developed regions.
14 October 2026 in Frontiers in Environmental Economics
Introduction: Livestock production in northern Kenya's arid and semi-arid rangelands is increasingly vulnerable to climate variability. The Index-Based Livestock Insurance (IBLI) program was introduced to mitigate drought-related losses by linking payouts to satellitederived Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI) thresholds. However, IBLI's efficacy may be hampered by basis risk -the discrepancy between actual losses and insurance payouts. This study examines how downside basis risk (losses without indemnity) is associated with pastoralist welfare and household consumption responses. Methods: Using data from the IBLI program (2019-2021) across eight Kenyan counties (Garissa, Isiolo, Mandera, Marsabit, Samburu, Tana River, Turkana, and Wajir), this study employs a two-stage empirical approach. First, quantile regression assesses the relationship between precipitation and forage availability. Second, a modified variance-of-error model quantifies the magnitude of basis risk. Results: The analysis reveals persistent downside basis risk across all counties and years, suggesting that households frequently incur losses without receiving insurance compensation. The findings demonstrate that repeated exposure to downside basis risk is associated with changes in pastoralists' consumption, which may ultimately lead to welfare losses. Discussion: While IBLI is designed to stabilize consumption, persistent downside basis risk undermines its welfare benefits and may erode trust in the insurance mechanism. To strengthen IBLI's potential to deliver sustainable welfare outcomes for pastoralist communities, future policy interventions must enhance index precision, revise subsidy structures, and incorporate behavioral considerations into program design.
Livestock production continues to serve as a critical foundation for livelihoods and economic resilience in the arid and semi-arid lands (ASALs) of northern Kenya, where pastoralism remains the dominant livelihood strategy. In the rangeland ecosystems of Turkana and West Pokot counties, the sustainability of pastoral systems is vital for the socio-economic well-being of local communities. However, these systems face increasing pressure from recurrent droughts and climate variability, which severely threaten forage availability and livestock productivity. These challenges underscore the urgent need for innovative and scalable risk management approaches. This study examines the effectiveness of Index-Based Livestock Insurance (IBLI) as a tool for supporting sustainable rangeland-based pastoral systems in northern Kenya. Specifically, it assesses the empirical impact of IBLI adoption using the Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI) as a proxy for forage availability. Employing a Difference-in-Differences (DID) approach with fixed effects, we analyze panel data derived from high-resolution MODIS-NASA satellite imagery spanning the years 2003 to 2021. The analysis focuses on determining the causal effects of IBLI adoption on rangeland health and pastoralist resilience in Turkana and West Pokot. Our findings indicate that IBLI adoption is associated with a statistically significant improvement in rangeland conditions, estimated at approximately 4%. Additional DID analyses suggest that this improvement is driven by enhanced forage sustenance, which itself shows a positive effect in the range of 3% to 4%. These results highlight the dual role of IBLI as both a household-level financial risk buffer and an enabler of ecological stability in pastoral systems. Overall, the study provides robust empirical evidence supporting the role of IBLI as an effective climate risk mitigation strategy. It contributes to the growing body of knowledge on sustainable pastoralism in ASALs and offers timely, policy-relevant insights for the expansion of IBLI programs across other drought-prone regions of Sub-Saharan Africa. By fostering both economic and ecological resilience, IBLI represents a promising pathway for strengthening the adaptive capacity of pastoralist communities in the face of escalating climate risks.