Reducing dependence on fossil-based feedstocks for packaging can be achieved through three complementary strategies: minimizing packaging use, increasing closed-loop recycling rates, and expanding the adoption of renewable (e.g., biobased) packaging materials. To ensure these defossilization pathways reinforce rather than hinder one another, it is essential to understand how new biobased materials interact with existing recycling streams. With the market introduction of packaging containing the biobased polyester poly(ethylene 2,5-furandicarboxylate) (PEF) approaching, several studies have investigated blends and copolyesters of poly(ethylene terephthalate) (PET) and PEF. This study expands current knowledge of thermomechanical and crystallization behavior by examining the influence of PEF on the mechanical recycling process of bottle-grade PET. Processing behavior was assessed at various PEF contents at both laboratory and industrial scales, and the resulting recycled resin and bottles were analyzed for color, crystallization behavior, and bottle performance. Although the melting temperature decreased with rising PEF content, no negative impact on the industrial recycling process investigated was observed for PEF levels up to 10 wt%. Two notable trends emerged: increasing PEF content reduced crystallization rate, yielding bottles with higher transparency, while yellowness also increased. Ongoing research aims to understand and mitigate this rise in yellowness.