Previous studies show that interventions to improve attitudes toward stuttering yield inconsistent results on the Public Opinion Survey of Human Attributes–Stuttering (POSHA–S). Comparisons of pre- and post-intervention samples indicate that success depends on the percentage of respondents who improved rather than the magnitude of change. A “crossover” effect emerged: respondents with the most positive pre-test attitudes showed lower post-test ratings, whereas those with the most negative pre-test attitudes showed the greatest improvement; respondents with intermediate attitudes showed little change. Similar patterns appeared in non-intervention samples, where one-third fell into positive, minimal, or negative change groups. The study analyzed 943 respondents from 29 intervention samples classified as unsuccessful (U), marginally successful (MS), successful (S), or very successful (VS), plus 345 respondents from 12 non-intervention samples. Using non-intervention data as a baseline, we calculated percentages shifting among the three change groups. In the VS category, interventions moved people from the negative and minimal change groups into the positive change group. In the S category, gains in the positive change group came from the negative change group. In the MS category, all intervention-related changes began in the negative change group, yielding modest growth in the positive and minimal change group. The U category showed shifts into both the positive and negative change group, mainly reducing the minimal change group. These findings suggest that interventions to improve attitudes toward stuttering should apply strategies tailored to individuals in positive, minimal, and negative change groups.
Background: Negative public attitudes promote undesirable stereotypes and stigma in stutterers. Method: To mitigate negative attitudes, 403 respondents combined from 16 international samples filled out the Public Opinion Survey of Human Attributes–Stuttering (POSHA–S) before and after interventions to improve attitudes and were compared to 249 respondents from seven control groups. Investigators aimed (a) to replicate an extreme case of regression to the mean (i.e., “crossover” effect) reported earlier in larger combined samples in which respondents with high pre-scores ended with low post-scores, respondents with low pre-scores finished with high post-scores, and intermediate scorers were unchanged; and (b) to identify individual POSHA–S items related to overall attitude change and among the high and low scorers. Results: As in previous studies, stuttering attitudes improved in the intervention group but not in the control group. Intervention and control respondents demonstrated “crossover” but less than the earlier samples due to lower pre–post correlations. Item contributions to pre–post change and differences among the three change groups were inconsistent; however, high agreement items by respondents were less likely to vary than low agreement items. Conclusion: The “crossover” effect was replicated, and future research should explore its presence in other measures or conditions.
Background: Negative public attitudes promote undesirable stereotypes and stigma in stutterers. Method: To mitigate negative attitudes, 16 international samples of 403 total respondents took the Public Opinion Survey of Human Attributes–Stuttering (POSHA–S) before and after interventions and were compared to seven combined control groups with 249 respondents. Investigators sought (a) to replicate an extreme case of regression to the mean, the “crossover” effect reported earlier in larger combined samples where negative changers with high pre-scores ended with low post-scores and positive changers with low pre-scores finished with the high post-scores and (b) to identify POSHA–S items related to attitudes overall change and among negative, minimal, and positive changers. Results: As in previous studies, stuttering attitudes improved in the intervention group but not the control group. Intervention and control respondents demonstrated “crossover” but less than the earlier samples due to lower pre-post correlations. Item contributions to pre-post change and differences among the three changer groups were inconsistent; however, high agreement items by respondents were less likely to vary than items with less unanimous agreement. Conclusion: The “crossover” effect was replicated, and future research should explore its presence in other measures or conditions.
About Me
Salman Abdi, PhD in Speech Therapy, Assistant Professor at Semnan University of Medical Sciences
Salman Abdi, PhD in Speech Therapy, Assistant Professor at Semnan University of Medical Sciences