In small ruminants, up to 40% of fertilized ova are lost during early gestation due to inadequate progesterone. This study evaluated post-transfer progestogen supplementation in goats. A total of 207 thawed embryos were transferred into 111 recipients assigned to progestogen-supplemented (n = 37) or non-progestogen-supplemented (n = 74) groups. Pregnancy and embryo survival did not differ between treatments (p > 0.05). However, fetal and neonatal survival were significantly lower in supplemented goats (29%) compared with non-supplemented goats (100%; p < 0.05). Infectious causes were excluded. Possible mechanisms postulated in fetal losses comprise a sharp decline in progesterone after sponge removal or increased oxytocin and prostaglandin due to vaginal mechanical stimulation, inducing luteolysis. In conclusion, intravaginal progestogen supplementation is not recommended for recipient goats in embryo transfer programs.