Digital fabrication with concrete is frequently promoted as a key technological solution to the sustainability crisis of the construction industry. Simultaneously, it is criticized for its large net material carbon footprint. Thus, the environmental impact should be assessed for a complete structural solution, representing three mutually dependent opportunities for resource efficiency: material, processing, and structural form. This paper presents a critical analysis of the resource efficiency of Shotcrete 3D Printing (SC3DP) slab through two parameters: mass and Global Warming Potential (GWP). Four scenarios are considered, utilising: (1) current state-of-the-art cast concrete, (2) reinforced SC3DP, (3) post-tensioned SC3DP, and (4) hybrid approach with cast plate and SC3DP ribs. Each design respects the opportunities and limitations of the given fabrication process, as based on the knowledge available from the previous research. Furthermore, two alternatives for SC3DP material concrete are considered, presenting a holistic approach. The results demonstrate that for the overly GWP-intensive SC3DP material, despite optimised form and lower mass, the slabs (2) and (3) have similar footprint as the reference, while the hybrid solution (4) offers reduction of the footprint by 20%–40%. However, with the use of the material tailored for the SC3DP process, all digitally-fabricated alternatives (2)–(4) demonstrate quite similar carbon footprint, being around 50% lower than the reference solution, but option (4) has higher mass, which would affect the resource efficiency of the whole building. As such, this research demonstrates the importance of consideration of material, process, and structural form in a holistic manner in order to provide resource-efficient design and fabrication alternatives for Net-Zero construction.