A previous paper from the Merseyside Group of Senior Registrars in Accident & Emergency Medicine examined the desirability of a logbook for Higher Specialist Training (HST) in accident & emergency medicine in the United Kingdom and its principal ingredients (Luke et al., 1991). A survey of 100 senior registrars and recently appointed consultants in the specialty identified the main issues of importance to the majority of respondents e.g. certification in advanced cardiac and trauma life support, a minimum of three years in the specialty before appointment as senior registrar and certain key secondments. In this paper, more senior consultants in the specialty were surveyed and a resounding majority concurred with the preferences of their junior colleagues. The findings are discussed and the implications for a future curriculum for postgraduate training in A&E medicine are explored.
1 January 2024 in Journal of Applied Learning & Teaching
The growing global teacher recruitment and retention crisis has ensured that discussions regarding how best to promote preparedness for classroom practice are more important than ever, with significant implications for initial teacher education (ITE). Adopting a multi-stage collaborative autoethnographic inquiry approach, this research paper contributes to the emerging field of simulation-based pedagogies (SBP) in ITE, as well as the strong research base in other disciplines, by outlining the impacts of working with student pedagogic consultants (SPCs) upon staff professional understanding of the effective planning and implementation of SBP. Findings suggest that working closely with SPCs affirmed staff pedagogic choices in deploying SBP, indicating a shared understanding of the benefits of simulation, and provided valuable insider perspectives to enhance staff pedagogic understanding and suggest improvements to the design of simulation sessions. However, accounts also highlight challenges experienced in the pedagogic consultancy process itself, including logistical concerns such as the use of time; discussions around power dynamics; and tensions arising from epistemological differences between staff and students. The authors conclude by advocating both the wider adoption of SBP in ITE and further exploration of working in partnership with students as SPCs to inform, and improve, the design and implementation of such pedagogies.
Simulation-based learning (SBL) is increasingly used within Initial Teacher Education (ITE) to bridge the gap between theory and practice, enhancing pre-service teachers’ (PSTs) preparedness for the complexities of classroom practice. Despite its growing adoption, limited research has examined how simulation design shapes PSTs’ learning experiences. This study addresses this gap by exploring PSTs’ experiences of two low-technology simulation modalities, mixed-media and multiple-choice formats, implemented within undergraduate primary ITE programmes at two UK universities. Using a sequential mixed-methods design, quantitative data were collected from 249 PSTs through the Educational Practices Questionnaire for Teacher Educators (EPQ-TE) and the Preparing Educators for Practice in Simulation Questionnaire (PEPS-Q), alongside qualitative data from open-text survey responses and focus groups. Findings indicate that PSTs reported high levels of perceived quality, engagement, and preparedness across both modalities, with no statistically significant differences between formats or institutions. Reflexive thematic analysis was used to explore simulation design features valued by PSTs, identifying three key themes: authenticity and realism, the benefits and challenges of peer collaboration, and the role of scaffolding and feedback in supporting professional learning. These findings suggest that learning in SBL emerges through the interaction of scenario design, learner participation, and tutor facilitation, offering practical insights for teacher educators seeking to design and implement simulation-based learning within ITE, as well as recommendations for future research.