Educational institutions are imbued with an institutional meritocratic discourse: only merit counts for academic success. In this article, we study whether this institutional belief has an impact beyond its primary function of encouraging students to study. We propose that belief in school meritocracy has broader societal impact by legitimizing the social class hierarchy it produces and encouraging the maintenance of inequalities. The results of four studies (one correlational study, Ntotal = 198; one experiment, Ntotal = 198; and two international data surveys, Ntotal = 88,421 in 40+countries) indicate that belief in school meritocracy reduces the perceived unfairness of social class inequality in society, support for affirmative action policies at university and support for policies aimed at reducing income inequality. Together, these studies show that the belief that schools are meritocratic carries consequences beyond the school context as it is associated with attitudes that maintain social class and economic inequality.
Les recherches sur le conflit sociocognitif (confrontation de points de vue entre partenaires) peuvent être utiles pour comprendre l’apprentissage dans les contextes collectifs. Cette synthèse présente les conditions qui rendent les conflits constructifs, inefficaces ou délétères pour l’apprentissage, à partir de travaux empiriques qui se sont souvent développés en parallèle : des travaux relatifs aux décisions collectives, à l’apprentissage coopératif, aux rôles des confrontations et des déstabilisations dans le développement des compétences cognitives, et à l’influence sociale. En particulier, la régulation du conflit dite sociocognitive ou épistémique, qui s’observe lorsque les apprenants sont centrés sur la résolution de la tâche, prend la forme d’une relation coopérative favorable à l’apprentissage. La régulation dite relationnelle, qui s’observe lorsque les apprenants sont focalisés exclusivement sur la comparaison sociale des compétences avec leur partenaire, entraîne soit de la complaisance, soit des confrontations compétitives. Les régulations relationnelles sont en général moins bénéfiques pour l’apprentissage que les régulations épistémiques.
Within psychology, the underachievement of students from working-class backgrounds has often been explained as a product of individual characteristics such as a lack of intelligence or motivation. Here, we propose an integrated model illustrating how educational contexts contribute to social class disparities in education over and beyond individual characteristics. According to this new Social Class-Academic Contexts Mismatch model, social class disparities in education are due to several mismatches between the experiences that students from working-class backgrounds bring with them to the classroom and those valued in academic contexts-specifically, mismatches between (a) academic contexts' culture of independence and the working-class orientation to interdependence, (b) academic contexts' culture of competition and the working-class orientation toward cooperation, (c) the knowledge valued in academic contexts and the knowledge developed through working-class socialization, and (d) the social identities valued in academic contexts and the negatively stereotyped social identities of students from working-class backgrounds. Because of these mismatches, students from working-class backgrounds are likely to experience discomfort and difficulty in the classroom. We further propose that, when attempting to make sense of these first-order effects, students and teachers rely on inherent characteristics (e.g., ability, motivation) more often than warranted; conversely, they overlook extrinsic, contextual factors. In turn, this explanatory bias toward inherent features leads (a) students from working-class backgrounds to experience self-threat and (b) their teachers to treat them unfairly. These second-order effects magnify social class disparities in education. This integrated model has the potential to reshape research and discourse on social class and education. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
22 December 2017 in European Journal of Social Psychology