Aqueous pyrolysis liquid (APL) is the water‑rich by‑product of pyrolysis with high organic content; however, it is too dilute for economical fuel upgrading, so practical applications remain limited. This study investigates the feasibility of co-digesting hydrolyzed sewage sludge filtrate with APL in high-rate anaerobic reactors to enhance energy recovery and as a treatment step for APL. Two lab-scale reactors were operated for >500 days: one fed with filtrate and APL, and a control fed with filtrate only. Results show that APL can be degraded at loadings up to 0.3 g CODAPL/L/d (≈2.1% w/w) without severe inhibition, achieving 93% CODAPL removal and stable methane production. Compared to previous studies, this work demonstrates substantially higher APL degradation under co-digestion conditions. Higher loadings (≥0.44 g CODAPL/L/d) caused inhibition despite recovery attempts. Microbial analysis revealed a shift from acetoclastic to hydrogenotrophic methanogenesis, dominated by Methanobacterium and Methanosarcina, alongside enrichment of taxa linked to resistance to a toxic environment. Measurements of pollutant concentration in effluent indicated partial degradation of low-molecular-weight polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and transformation of some polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS), though most pollutants persisted in effluent. These findings highlight the potential of high-rate reactors for APL treatment and underscore the need for strategies such as inoculum acclimation, pretreatment, or additives to achieve industrial-scale loadings. The study provides insights into microbial resilience, pollutant fate, and operational considerations for integrated anaerobic digestion–pyrolysis systems.