This article investigates the design and optimization of a high-speed surface-mounted permanent magnet synchronous motor with an amorphous stator core for hydrogen compressor applications, where high efficiency and high power density are critical. Amorphous materials offer significant potential for reducing excessive core losses at high electrical frequencies—a key requirement for high-speed hydrogen compression systems. However, manufacturing processes such as annealing and cutting degrade their magnetic properties, making raw ribbon data insufficient for accurate loss calculation. To address this, the magnetic performance degradation of the processed amorphous core is characterized by introducing a loss modification factor, improving core loss prediction accuracy. Based on a conventional silicon steel baseline motor operating at 60,000 rpm, a finite element model incorporating the corrected amorphous loss data is developed by replacing the stator core with amorphous material. The Dowell analytical model for AC windings is employed to accelerate computation. A multi-objective evolutionary algorithm is then applied to optimize the motor geometry, maximizing efficiency while maintaining output power to meet the demanding requirements of hydrogen compressors. Finally, a prototype is manufactured and tested. The experimental results validate the efficiency improvement of the amorphous material-based motor and confirm the effectiveness of the proposed optimization methodology for hydrogen compressor applications.