The problem of loneliness is receiving increasing attention in the popular media and among social scientists. Despite anthropology's rich engagement with emotions and experience, the anthropology of loneliness is still scant. In psychology, loneliness has been defined as relational lack. In this article, I reconsider one culturally specific form of relational lack—being unneeded among post-Soviet Muscovites. I draw on the anthropological literature on emotion, exchange, and morality to suggest that being unneeded is an ethical commentary on a lack of recognition. During Soviet times, recognition was secured through informal social exchange practices. Being unneeded among middle-aged and elderly post-Soviet Muscovites is therefore connected to a constricted ability to give and experience recognition. One avenue of analysis for an anthropology of loneliness is to consider social exchange practices and how these connect with societal and moral dimensions of loneliness.
The Decisions At Menopause Study (DAMES) investigates the experience of menopause in four countries. This article explores self-reported health. Women aged 45 to 55 years were interviewed in Lebanon (n=298), Morocco (n=299), Spain (n=300), and the United States (n=293). The survey instrument included closed- and open-ended questions. Statistical analyses were used to assess the determinants of reporting poor health, and textual analyses were used to highlight themes related to perceptions of health. In Lebanon and Morocco, 22% and 28%, respectively, of the women sampled indicated that their health was not good. In Spain and the United States, 15% and 11% of the women sampled reported their health as fair or poor. We explored significant predictors of poorer reported health across sites. Responses to the open-ended questions "How is your health?" and "How do you compare your health to other women your own age?" revealed common concerns of aches and pains, tiredness, work/responsibilities, and family across all four sites. Unique themes included the war in Lebanon, poverty in Morocco, and social activity in Spain. Menopausal symptoms may in many cases be overshadowed by other health concerns of middle-aged women. Nonspecific symptoms such as tiredness and aches and pains serve to link bodily health with social circumstances. Family and work responsibilities are common concerns of middle-aged women. Research on midlife health and menopause needs to be systematic enough to enable cross-cultural comparisons. At the same time, it must be flexible enough to identify population-specific symptoms, social context, and lifestyle concerns.