The relative importance of density dependence regulation in natural population fluctuations has long been debated. The concept of density dependence implies that current abundance is determined by historical abundance. We have developed four models—two density dependent and two density independent—to predict population size one year beyond the training set and used predictive performance on more than 16,000 populations from 14 datasets to compare the understanding captured by those models. For 4 of 14 datasets the density dependent models make better predictions (i.e., density dependent regulated) than either of the density independent models. However, neither of the density dependent models is statistically significantly superior to density independent models for any of the 14 datasets. We conclude that the evidence for widespread density dependent population regulation in the forms represented by these two simple density-dependent models is weak. However, the density dependent models used here—the Logistic and Gompertz models—are simple representations of how population density might regulate natural populations and only examine density-dependent effects on population size. A comprehensive assessment of the relative importance of density-dependent population regulation will require testing the predictive ability of a wider range of density-dependent models including models examining effects on population characteristics other than population size.
The relative importance of density dependence regulation in natural population fluctuations has long been debated1-3. The concept of density dependence implies that current abundance is determined by historical abundance. We have developed four models – two density dependent and two density independent - to predict population size one year beyond the training set and used predictive performance on more than 16,000 populations from 14 datasets to compare the understanding captured by those models. For 4 of 14 datasets the density dependent models make better predictions (i.e., density dependent regulated) than either of the density independent models. However, neither of the density dependent models is statistically significantly superior to density independent models for any of the 14 datasets. We conclude that the evidence for widespread density dependent population regulation is weak.
The debate about the relative importance of interspecific competition and environmental factors in annual population fluctuations has persisted in ecology for many decades. Ecologists face the challenge of determining the extent to which interspecific competition and environmental factors impact population growth rates. We assess the predictive ability of models with and without interspecific competition and environmental covariates to predict population size one year beyond the model-building data. For 11 of 14 datasets a model with interspecific competition and/or environmental factors make better mean ‘absolute’ prediction error. However, none of the models with interspecific competition and/or environmental variables make predictions that are statistically significantly superior to the random walk model. Overall, in about 60% of the sites, models with interspecific competition and environmental variables show performance worse than the random walk baseline model on independent data. We conclude that there is weak evidence that incorporating interspecific competition and/or environmental covariates leads to improved model predictive ability. A thorough assessment of the relative importance of interspecific competition and environmental factors in annual population fluctuations will require evaluating the predictive power of a broader range of models that incorporate ecology of species traits at each generational time.