The growing influence of social media personalities in shaping consumer behavior presents significant opportunities and challenges for marketers. This research integrates Social Identity Theory with the influencer marketing literature to investigate how influencer self-disclosure affects word-of-mouth intentions through consumer identification. Across four experiments (N = 1048), we demonstrate that high influencer self-disclosure consistently increases consumers’ word-of-mouth intentions compared to low self-disclosure. Consumer identification with the influencer mediates this relationship, providing a psychological mechanism through which personal narratives translate into advocacy behaviors. Furthermore, we identify two important boundary conditions: self-concept clarity moderates the relationship between self-disclosure and identification, with stronger effects for consumers experiencing identity uncertainty; and cultural collectivism orientation moderates the identification-to-WOM pathway, with collectivistic mindsets amplifying the translation of identification into advocacy. These findings contribute to both theory and practice by elucidating the psychological processes underlying influencer effectiveness and offer strategic guidance for optimizing influencer communication across diverse consumer segments and cultural contexts.
Influencer marketing practice predominantly favors same-niche partnerships; however, industry evidence suggests that unconventional pairings can sometimes outperform traditional matches, highlighting a knowledge gap regarding how collaboration structure influences consumer response. Drawing on Optimal Distinctiveness Theory, this research examines whether cross-niche collaborations enhance brand evaluations by fulfilling concurrent desires for inclusion and differentiation. Four controlled experiments (total N = 1482) employing Instagram-style stimuli and behavioral intention measures compare same- versus cross-niche alliances while manipulating or measuring consumers’ need for uniqueness and category expertise. Across studies, cross-niche (versus same-niche) collaborations consistently improve brand attitude, an effect fully mediated by heightened perceptions of brand innovation. Moderation analyses reveal that this indirect effect is amplified among consumers high in need for uniqueness but attenuated—and in some cases reversed—among category experts, who tend to prefer the depth signaled by same-niche partnerships. Alternative explanations, including curiosity, source credibility, and message liking, are empirically ruled out. These findings extend Optimal Distinctiveness Theory to influencer branding by identifying collaboration type as a market-level cue signaling innovation while refining influencer effectiveness models through a dual-contingency framework that incorporates motivational and knowledge-based audience factors. From a managerial perspective, the results suggest deploying cross-niche alliances when targeting novelty-seeking or novice segments while preserving niche purity or offering technical justification when addressing expert consumers, thereby aligning collaboration strategies with audience composition.