Purpose: The study examines the benefits and potential challenges of the mentoring circle as an innovative approach to mentoring among four cisgendered women faculty situated at 4-year universities in various geographic locations in the United States.Design/methodology/approach: Utilizing collaborative autoethnography, we ask: How can mentoring circles be beneficial for diverse early- and mid-career faculty women in higher education? Given our varying positionalities and the development of our sustained mentoring relationships, we drew on the concepts of intersectionality and sisterhood as a framework to understand our individual and collective experiences in the circle. Through a collaborative autoethnographic design, we examined data from four 3-h online video reflective discussions as well as relevant documents and communication, such as emails and texts.Findings: The power dynamics within the circle, fluidity of its borders and how it provided us with a unique ability to read the world contributed to a sense of community and empowerment that were key factors to the circle's success. We created an inclusive space with a defined purpose where trust, authenticity, reciprocity and the expectation for vulnerability served as the solid foundation for relationships. We became sources of holistic support, sharing advice and resources to support our growth as teachers, scholars and community members within our field and beyond.Originality/value: Our mentoring circle disrupts conventional mentoring structures and highlights the power of a sustainable circle among diverse women faculty rooted in adaptive, flexible and responsive relationships.
The current study utilizes feminist life course theory to examine the perspectives of women who have aspired or have entered into the superintendency in the United States. Life course theory suggests that our “role histories” often inform our choices about careers. The role histories reflect instantaneous responses to the social cues of our external world. Consequently, it offers opportunity to understand how patterns of socialization may impact real-life decisions over career possibilities (and impossibilities) and the historical conditions in which career decisions are made. Using survey responses from current and aspiring female superintendents (n = 133), we engaged in descriptive and inferential statistical analyses. We contextualized these findings further through the four principles of life course theory, historical time and place, timing in lives, linked lives, and human agency. Our findings indicate women’s perspectives on the accessibility of the superintendency have shifted as narratives around women’s executive leadership roles have also changed. Importantly, the women in this study view accessibility to the superintendency as a largely contingent decision – a strategic, individual-level assessment focusing on the favorability of district work conditions to their success as leaders. Simultaneously, we see where issues of social networking, leadership “tapping,” and district “fit” emerge as normative expectations for accessing leadership roles as well as the preferred conditions upon which such choices are made. This reflects an encouraging perspective shift in which women are focusing less on “feasibility” than on “fit.” We conclude by offering recommendations for practice.
This study explores the integration of generative artificial intelligence (AI) into qualitative research within a higher education context. Through a collaborative self-study, a doctoral candidate and their dissertation supervisor examined the application of Google’s Gemini 1.5 to analyze interview data from a dissertation of practice (DiP) focused on interinstitutional partnerships. The findings demonstrate that AI can enhance the depth and efficiency of qualitative analysis, revealing hidden complexities and patterns while augmenting the researcher's analytical skills and fostering reflexivity. However, challenges related to data integrity, potential biases, and the need for careful human oversight are also discussed. This research offers insights into the transformative potential of AI in qualitative research, particularly within doctoral education, while raising important ethical considerations and prompting a re-evaluation of traditional dissertation practices in the context of emerging technologies.
In education, where caregiving is paramount, the role of wom(b)an educators who are childfree—whether by choice or circumstance—introduces complex dynamics of identity and expectation. This chapter shares a collaborative autoethnography involving four racially and ethnically diverse female faculty from universities across the U.S. who are part of a co-mentoring circle. They navigate their professional landscapes while grappling with societal and cultural expectations. The chapter delves into the testimonios to explore the nuanced experiences of being childfree wom(b)an faculty, examining how these experiences shape their scholarship, teaching, and engagement in academia. It investigates how broader sociocultural perceptions of wom(b)anhood influence their professional lives and the norms within academic settings. By weaving their stories, this work sheds light on the paradoxical freedom associated with their status, the impact on professional identity, and the balance between work and personal life.
8 September 2025 in Journal of Women and Gender in Higher Education