Reliable hunting bag statistics are a prerequisite for sustainable harvest management based on quantitative modeling. Estimating the total hunting bag for a given game species is faced with a multiplicity of error sources. Of particular concern is the nonresponse error. We consider that the major cause of nonresponse bias is when the reluctance to respond is related to a null harvest, which leads to a potentially important overestimation. For tackling the nonresponse bias issue, we advocate the repeated subsampling of nonrespondents, with a final phase of personal interview by phone, intended to be without nonresponse. When a 100% response rate is actually reached at the last phase, both total and sampling variance can be estimated without bias, whatever the response rates at the previous phases. The actual case of imperfect response at the last phase is studied using Monte Carlo simulations. For imperfect response at the last phase, we show that the estimators we advocate are biased downwards but that these bias remain very moderate if the response rate at the last phase is high enough, depending on the circumstances. Furthermore, we illustrate that increasing the number of phases improves the nonresponse bias attenuation. In case of a hunting bag collecting scheme prone to a high nonresponse rate, for obtaining a very satisfying nonresponse bias attenuation we advocate relying on the multiphase sampling strategy with two- or three-phases, and a response rate in the last phase of at least 90%.
3 August 2020 in European Journal of Wildlife Research
The Hanurav-Vijayan procedure belongs to the class of exact, draw-by-draw algorithms for unequal probability sampling without replacement. This procedure has been implemented in market-leading commercial statistical packages such as SAS/STAT and SPSS, which have popularized its use. Unfortunately, the description of the Hanurav-Vijayan procedure in the documentation of these softwares is partially flawed, propagating errors issued from the statistical literature. Besides, despite it is often used, this procedure has almost fallen in oblivion in the literature devoted to sampling probability designs, and no comparisons were made with other competing methods. It is the purpose of the present paper to rehabilitate the Hanurav-Vijayan procedure by correctly describing its implementation details and providing some basic elements of comparison with the well-known Rao-Sampford procedure.