In this study, we designed an educational experiment to evaluate the High Impact Leadership for School Renewal project’s impact on principal leadership, school leadership, and student achievement. Principals in the experimental group reported statistically significantly greater improvement in principal leadership than their counterparts in the control group (Hedge’s g of 0.73), but teachers in the experimental and control groups showed no difference in their ratings of principal leadership. Teachers in the experimental group reported statistically significantly more improvement in school leadership than their counterparts in the control group (Hedge’s g of 0.53 on the scale of Orientation to School Renewal and 0.58 on the scale of Learning-Centered School Leadership), but principals in the two groups reported no difference in the growth in school leadership. Schools in the experimental group showed statistically significantly larger annual growth in English language arts proficiency rate (2.05 percentage points more annually). The implications of the findings were discussed in the context of leadership development programs for school improvement.
This chapter reviews instruments that have been used for measuring teacher leadership over the past two decades. We examined the types, content, and psychometric properties of 16 representative instruments. Beyond this, we analysed the utilisation of these instruments in empirical studies. The key findings were as follows: (a) the theoretical frameworks used in teacher leadership instruments are still inconsistent; (b) there is still a need for a common understanding of the dimensions constituting the construct teacher leadership for developing and validating teacher leadership instruments; (c) nearly half of the instruments did not provide sufficient psychometric evidence to demonstrate the reliability and validity of the instruments. We suggest that future empirical research need to utilise the instruments that enhance teacher leadership practice and improve other school outcomes. <!----> <!----> <!----> <!---->
18 August 2026 in Journal of Educational Administration
Purpose: This study (a) examines the association between two school renewal instruments – High Integrity and Fidelity Implementation for School Renewal (HIFI) and School Renewal Principles and Practices (PP) – and school-level student achievement, and (b) assesses whether these instruments can serve as practical tools for guiding school improvement. Design/methodology/approach: Survey data from 1,420 teachers across 83 elementary and middle schools were aggregated to the school level and combined with public school performance data from the Michigan Student Test of Educational Progress (M-STEP). Multiple regression and lagged-achievement models were employed to examine the associations between school renewal measures and student achievement outcomes. Findings: Both HIFI and PP were positively associated with school mathematics and English language arts proficiency rates and annual gains. Schools with stronger renewal practices were associated with higher proficiency rates and greater year-to-year growth. Implementation integrity showed relatively more consistent associations with school performance across models. Originality/value: This study provides additional evidence on the associations of two school renewal instruments with school-level achievement and year-to-year changes in achievement. It provides valid measures for future research on leadership and school effectiveness.
Teacher leadership has gained increasing attention since the 1980s. With the various operationalizations of teacher leadership in research and practice as well as mixed results of effects of teacher leadership, we sought to investigate the difference in teacher leadership under the school reform and renewal approaches. We delineated nuanced differences in teacher leadership under the two approaches and provided empirical illustrations, including (a) boundary spanning vs. embedded co-construction, (b) compliant sense-making vs. holistic, generative sense-making, (c) episodic, task-based engagement vs. sustained, identity-based stewardship, (d) initiative-driven activation vs. developmental capacity building, and (e) parallel leadership vs. integrated leadership. The illustrations were based on three large school leadership projects conducted from 2017 to the present. The article creates a nuanced understanding of teacher leadership by situating its construct and practice in a larger school improvement context.