Cyanobacteria dominate ecosystems ranging from oligotrophic deserts to eutrophic lakes, yet it remains unclear whether distantly related species thrive in disparate habitats through shared genomic foundations or divergent specialization. Here, we address this question using Microcoleus vaginatus, the pioneer stabilizer of biocrusts, and Microcystis aeruginosa, the agent of freshwater blooms worldwide, as contrasting models of terrestrial and aquatic dominance. We assembled a comparative framework of 504 high-quality cyanobacterial genomes, including 132 M. vaginatus, 148 M. aeruginosa, and 224 reference taxa, and jointly analyzed genome architecture, functional repertoires, and genomic plasticity. Despite phylogenetic separation, both species share high rates of horizontal gene transfer and retain a compact, conserved functional core centered on FAD-dependent oxidoreductases, manganese efflux, and class II aldolases that collectively maintain redox balance, photosynthetic performance, and metabolic robustness. Nevertheless, the two lineages followed contrasting genomic strategies that M. vaginatus expands regulatory breadth and stress-resilience gene families, whereas M. aeruginosa shows genome streamlining and rapid exploitation. Notably, aquatic M. vaginatus strains retain terrestrial genomic scaffolds while gradually rewiring plasticity mechanisms and niche-specific functions. Together, these results reveal a two-tier architecture of cyanobacterial dominance, a conserved survival core coupled with divergent adaptive peripheries. It offers a predictive framework for how cyanobacterial lineages will respond to the global-change pressures.