The hadron loop effect is conjectured to be important in understanding discrepancies between the observed states in experiments and the theoretical expectations of the nonrelativistic potential model. We present that in an easily operable procedure the hadron loop effect could shift the poles downwards to reduce the differences and provide better descriptions of both the masses and the total widths, at least, of the radial quantum number n=1 charmed and charmed-strange states. The 11P1-13P1 mixing phenomena could be naturally explained due to their couplings with common channels. The newly observed D states are also addressed, but there are still some problems that remain unclear.
By using a combined amplitude analysis of the and data, we demonstrate that the , which is quoted as a state in the Particle Data Group table, is favored by the data to be a state appearing in both channels, which means that the and the can be regarded as the same state. Meanwhile, the data also prefer a large helicity-0 contribution of this tensor resonance to the amplitudes instead of the helicity-2 dominance assumed by BABAR, which may indicate a sizable portion of non- components in this state. Identifying the with the and abandoning the helicity-2 dominance for this tensor state are helpful for the further understandings of the properties of this state and also of the mysterious “” charmoniumlike resonances.
We developed a Friedrichs-model-like scheme in studying the hadron resonance phenomenology and present that the hadron resonances might be regarded as the Gamow states produced by a Hamiltonian in which the bare discrete state is described by the result of the usual quark potential model and the interaction part is described by the quark pair creation model. In an almost parameter-free calculation, the , , and state could be simultaneously produced with a quite good accuracy by coupling the three P-wave states, , , predicted in the Godfrey-Isgur model to the , , continuum states. At the same time, we predict that the state is at about 3890 MeV with a pole width of about 44 MeV. In this calculation, the state has a large compositeness. This scheme may shed more light on the long-standing problem about the general discrepancy between the prediction of the quark model and the observed values, and it may also provide reference for future search for the hadron resonance state.
We study the well-known Friedrichs model, in which a discrete state is coupled to a continuum state. By examining the pole behaviors of the Friedrichs model in a specific form factor thoroughly, we find that, in general, when the bare discrete state is below the threshold of the continuum state, there should also be a virtual-state pole accompanying the bound-state pole originating from the bare discrete state as the coupling is turned on. There are also other second-sheet poles originating from the singularities of the form factor. We give a general argument for the existence of these two kinds of states. As the coupling is increased to a certain value, the second-sheet poles may merge and become higher-order poles. We then discuss the completeness relations incorporating bound states, virtual states, and resonant states corresponding to higher-order poles.