Kucha, a unique tea germplasm rich in theacrine, imparts its fresh leaves with a particularly bitter taste and multiple bioactivities. However, systematic studies on processed Kucha—especially white tea—remain limited. In this study, white teas were produced from two Yunnan Kucha accessions (YLKC1, YLKC2) and two conventional cultivars. Their quality characteristics and non-volatile metabolic profiles were systematically compared using sensory evaluation, targeted quantification and widely targeted metabolomics. Results indicated that Kucha white teas displayed pronounced bitterness, with YLKC1 presenting a richer, well-layered flavor, indicating promising quality potential. Targeted quantification demonstrated a remarkably high theacrine content (~30 mg/g) in Kucha white teas, whereas caffeine and several catechin monomers were significantly lower than those in conventional cultivars. Widely targeted metabolomic analysis identified 3376 non-volatile metabolites. PCA and OPLS-DA demonstrated a clear separation in metabolic profiles between Kucha and control groups. In total, 601 significantly differential metabolites were identified. Taste-driven annotation against ChemTastesDB revealed 17 known bitter compounds, 10 of which were significantly accumulated in Kucha white tea—including theacrine, theophylline, theobromine, L-arginine, neohesperidin, pinocembrin, kaempferol-3-O-(6”-malonyl)glucoside, fraxin, adenosine, and xanthine. Among these compounds, theacrine showed the highest upregulation (9.30-fold). In addition, several galloylated flavonoid glycosides also exhibited significant accumulation. KEGG enrichment analysis further indicated that flavonoid biosynthesis and caffeine metabolism were crucial pathways contributing to these metabolic differences. Collectively, these findings demonstrate that the characteristic bitterness of Kucha white tea arises from the coordinated accumulation of a specific set of bitter phytochemicals rather than a single compound and provide a prioritized panel of candidate compounds for flavor-oriented breeding and processing.