Many small-scale fisheries (SSFs) in Latin America and the Caribbean (LAC) operate in ecologically sensitive areas, where balancing conservation and resource use is challenging. 'Multiple-use' marine protected areas (MPAs) have been implemented to accommodate SSFs (among other uses) within areas designated for conservation, creating opportunities and challenges for SSF governance. We analyzed eleven case studies from LAC to explore: (1) how different MPA institutional designs affect key aspects of SSF governance and (2) the links between these effects and the type of initiative that promoted MPA establishment (origin). Results indicate that the existence of an MPA benefited SSF governance in many ways, with more pronounced positive effects in MPAs with mixed to bottom-up origin supported by well-organized fishing groups. In addition, the presence of supportive MPA authorities that leveraged local capacities and initiatives and adopted flexible and collaborative governance systems made a difference in several cases. Lessons for integrating MPA and SSF governance are drawn.
The purpose of this study is to analyze how octopus collectors (pulperos) built a place and gave a sense of place to a dirt road along a stretch paralleling and bordering the Atlantic coast of Patagonia from 1950 to 1970. A qualitative and participatory methodology was used, based on these ethnographic techniques: interviews, in-depth interviews, field trips and geographical referencing of the places recognized by the pulperos. As a result, informants identified places where pulperos used to settle down; these places were mapped and given toponyms recognized by them. The limitation of the study is that it did not delve into the transformations of the road, although its originality lies in the use of the concepts of paraje (place), sense of place and landscape in the reconstruction of the road on the basis of a artisanal production activity. In conclusion, affections residing in pulperos’ memory were central in the social construction of the road and the parajes as a place in the geographical sense.
16 January 2024 in Aquatic Conservation: Marine and Freshwater Ecosystems
Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) are key tools for mitigating the impacts of human activities on marine biodiversity and addressing climate change. Consequently, nations worldwide have committed to international targets to expand MPA coverage, leading to a rapid increase in protected areas and generating significant challenges for financing and effective management, particularly in developing countries. Under this scenario, multiple stakeholders, including local communities, academia, governments, and national and international organizations, are joining efforts to reduce financial gaps and strengthen MPA governance and management. In this study, we present the case of the Juan Fernández Archipelago in Chile, where multiple organizations collaborated to develop a socially robust and locally grounded governance system for a network of MPAs through a comprehensive community engagement process conducted on Robinson Crusoe Island between 2022 and 2024. As a result, a Functional Community Organization was established to co-manage the MPAs with the Chilean government, and three MPA management plans encompassing ~580,000 km2 were approved. Among them, the management plan of the Multiple-Use MPA “Mar de Juan Fernández” was the first approved under the new Chilean Biodiversity and Protected Areas Service (Law 21,600), setting a national precedent for co-management. Our findings show that effective MPA governance depends not only on institutional design but also on the extent to which governance arrangements are socially embedded and locally legitimate. In this context, community-grounded and context-sensitive engagement processes facilitated high levels of participation, strengthened representation, and supported the co-production of knowledge, providing a strong foundation for the long-term implementation of conservation objectives.