Urban forests support wildlife populations across North America and the world. Yet, challenges remain for research and practice to integrate wildlife habitat as a core component of the myriad objectives that urban foresters manage. Ecosystem services have been adopted as a dominant paradigm in urban forestry for both advocacy and management, yet accounting for contributions to wildlife habitat does not fit squarely within typical ecosystem service frameworks. The i-Tree program, a suite of urban forest ecosystem service models and tools developed by the US Forest Service, presented an opportunity to link widely used urban forest assessment field protocols with indicators of suitable habitat. In this reflection piece, we demonstrate how the i-Tree Wildlife project assessed whether urban forest structural assessment methods could be applied to assess wildlife habitat provision, operationalizing the fundamental question “How do urban forests support wildlife?” We describe the development process for integrating bird habitat suitability models for 12 species present in the northeastern US, ten native and two non-native birds, into the flagship i-Tree Eco tool. We offer reflections, challenges, and opportunities from this process. Ultimately, the improvement of ecosystem assessment tools like i-Tree can assist practitioners who aim to manage healthy and productive urban forests that benefit people and wildlife.