The construct of identity is increasingly recognized as a dominant and determining aspect in learning mathematics. While researchers—collectively—theorize identity as situated and negotiated, they also draw attention to the unwieldy nature of the concept that makes it difficult to define and operationalize. The purpose of this paper is to contribute to the conversation on identity in mathematics education by providing a literature review through the lens of a four-part networked identity model configured by Ivanič ( 1998 ) in the field of academic writing. Following a short introduction of the meaning of identity as a research construct, the paper discusses Ivanič’s four identity-related aspects that include autobiographical identity, discoursal identity, authorial identity, and socioculturally available identities. It then examines research in K-12 mathematics education that focuses on learners’ identity through the perspective of Ivanič’s model to suggest an instrumental, yet tentative, multi-dimensional framework for exploring identity in mathematics education. The paper concludes with potential trajectories for future research.
In this paper, we put center stage the story of a community in the borderland of Palomas and Deming, two twin towns located across the border from each other. In regular times, almost a thousand children crossed the checkpoint every day from Palomas in Mexico to Deming in the United States to attend school. During the COVID-19 pandemic, accessibility to education has been almost completely denied for students living in Mexico. This paper unpacks the findings from a critical case study focused on the school leadership of the community and marks the beginning of a larger action-research initiative aimed at forging alliances with and among community stakeholders, researchers, and community leaders to bring transformative change. Findings suggest that these borderland cities do not view themselves as divided by a physical or ideological Frontera or Barrera. Rather, they see themselves as a unified community whose members live on both sides of the border. The Palomas-Deming borderland community shares one mission of creating the necessary conditions to provide educational equity for all students in the region with U.S. passports regardless of a student’s country of residence. Within these contexts, our paper adds to the sparse scholarship on borderland education and highlights community-based needs for and capabilities of transformative educational change that we perceive as the pathway to more equitable opportunities for learning.
21 April 2025 in European Educational Research Journal
The year 2020 will be remembered as the time when the COVID-19 pandemic swept the world. Almost overnight, all educational activities pivoted to online platforms and teaching and learning was navigated in uncharted terrains. In mathematics education, concerns about sustaining online teaching and learning of mathematics have generated efforts in using digital technologies. In this paper, we use the lens of complexity theory and in particular the constructs of agents, interaction, dispersed control, and emergence to describe top-down and bottom-up mechanisms for change within the sudden shift to emergency remote teaching and learning. The authors’ collaborative work was carried out through online meetings discussing observations on and insights about their experience as mathematics teacher educators during the COVID-19 pandemic and traction data in three locally available online platforms. The main findings indicate two government-led, top-down initiatives, and three community-led bottom-up initiatives. The results suggest that mathematics teachers, mathematics teacher educators, and mathematics teacher consultants served as actors within the larger system. We discuss the possibilities and constraints of mathematics education in a time of crisis through the lens of complexity theory and offer trajectories for further research.