In response to the problems of deteriorating quality of newly added reserves of deep and ultra-deep shale oil, significant differences in well efficiency among similar sweet spots, and difficulty in converting resources and production capacity, a deep and ultra-deep shale oil resource conversion evaluation method is proposed based on the entire process of shale oil development. Based on the production dynamics during the initial stage of production, we establish oil well classification standards for deep and ultra-deep shale oil and obtain two types of shale oil development unit classification standards. We construct well efficiency response indicators for development units, well efficiency index and well efficiency index, quantitatively characterizing the comprehensive well efficiency response within the development unit. We construct a production capacity evaluation system for the development of sweet spots that integrates resource utilization, technological economy, and business management. We use the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method to obtain sweet spot evaluation scores and grades and quantitatively characterize the differences in production capacity construction for the development of sweet spots. On this basis, the “Resource–Productivity Matching Five Step Method” is proposed, which couples the sweet spot evaluation results with the well efficiency index to obtain the final score and evaluation results of resource conversion. The instance application of the M development unit shows that its overall resource conversion efficiency is not high, with only one type of area being a good match and the other areas being basic matches. The evaluation results are relative. This method achieves the integration of “sweet spot advantage (comprehensive score)—well efficiency response (well efficiency index)—conversion effect (final score)” and can identify false matches, improve the objectivity and reliability of evaluation results, and provide a scientific basis and technical support for shale oil block screening, well location deployment, construction planning and other research.