John Peabody

Dr. John Peabody

orcid

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

28Years (1999-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
5 April 2000 in JAMA
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JPJohn Peabody
John Peabody
JLJeff Luck
Jeff Luck
PGPeter Glassman
Peter Glassman
TDTimothy R. Dresselhaus
Timothy R. Dresselhaus
MLMartin Lee
Martin Lee
Assessing quality must ultimately rely on measures that are inexpensive, reliable, and able to adequately control for case-mix variation.1-3 Health outcome measures, although a direct assessment of health status, also reflect a spectrum of confounding events such as comorbidities and the socioeconomic determinants of health—factors that are generally beyond the control of a physician's daily practice. As a result, process measures of quality are increasingly being used.4,5 If linkages between the provision of care and better health status have been firmly established, there are substantiated benefits to measuring process over measuring outcomes.6 Processes can be measured more frequently than outcomes (eg, a death or complication), do not require a lengthy interval to become manifest,7 and are generally less expensive to monitor.8,9

16 November 2004 in Annals of Internal Medicine
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
JPJohn Peabody
John Peabody
JLJeff Luck
Jeff Luck
PGPeter Glassman
Peter Glassman
SJSharad Jain
Sharad Jain
JHJoyce Hansen
Joyce Hansen
MLMartin Lee
Martin Lee
Worldwide efforts are under way to improve the quality of clinical practice. Most quality measurements, however, are poorly validated, expensive, and difficult to compare among sites. To validate whether vignettes accurately measure the quality of clinical practice by using a comparison with standardized patients (the gold standard method), and to determine whether vignettes are a more or less accurate method than medical record abstraction. Prospective, multisite study. Outpatient primary care clinics in 2 Veterans Affairs medical centers and 2 large, private medical centers. 144 of 163 eligible physicians agreed to participate, and, of these, 116 were randomly selected to see standardized patients, to complete vignettes, or both. Scores, expressed as the percentage of explicit quality criteria correctly completed, were obtained by using 3 methods. Among all physicians, the quality of clinical practice as measured by the standardized patients was 73% correct (95% CI, 72.1% to 73.4%). By using exactly the same criteria, physicians scored 68% (CI, 67.9% to 68.9%) when measured by the vignettes but only 63% (CI, 62.7% to 64.0%) when assessed by medical record abstraction. These findings were consistent across all diseases and were independent of case complexity or physician training level. Vignettes also accurately measured unnecessary care. Finally, vignettes seem to capture the range in the quality of clinical practice among physicians within a site. Despite finding variation in the quality of clinical practice, we did not determine whether poorer quality translated into worse health status for patients. In addition, the quality scores are based on measurements from 1 patient–provider interaction. As with all other scoring criteria, vignette criteria must be regularly updated. Vignettes are a valid tool for measuring the quality of clinical practice. They can be used for diverse clinical settings, diseases, physician types, and situations in which case-mix variation is a concern. They are inexpensive and easy to use. Vignettes are particularly useful for comparing quality among and within sites and may be useful for longitudinal evaluations of interventions intended to change clinical practice.

1 November 2004 in Medical Care
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JPJohn Peabody
John Peabody
JLJeff Luck
Jeff Luck
SJSharad Jain
Sharad Jain
DBDan Bertenthal
Dan Bertenthal
PGPeter Glassman
Peter Glassman
Administrative data play a central role in health care. Inaccuracies in such data are costly to health systems, they obscure health research, and they affect the quality of patient care. We sought to prospectively determine the accuracy of the primary and secondary diagnoses recorded in administrative data sets. Between March and July 2002, standardized patients (SPs) completed unannounced visits at 3 sites. We abstracted the 348 medical records from these visits to obtain the written diagnoses made by physicians. We also examined the patient files to identify the diagnoses recorded on the administrative encounter forms and extracted data from the computerized administrative databases. Because the correct diagnosis was defined by the SP visit, we could determine whether the final diagnosis in the administrative data set was correct and, if not, whether it was caused by physician diagnostic error, missing encounter forms, or incorrectly filled out forms. General internal medicine outpatient clinics at 2 Veterans Administration facilities and a large, private medical center participated in this study. A total of 45 trained SPs presented to physicians with 4 common outpatient conditions. The correct primary diagnosis was recorded for 57% of visits. Thirteen percent of errors were caused by physician diagnostic error, 8% to missing encounter forms, and 22% to incorrectly entered data. Findings varied by condition and site but not by level of training. Accuracy of secondary diagnosis data (27%) was even poorer. Although more research is needed to evaluate the cause of inaccuracies and the relative contributions of patient, provider, and system level effects, it appears that significant inaccuracies in administrative data are common. Interventions aimed at correcting these errors appear feasible.

28 September 2002 in BMJ
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
JLJeff Luck
Jeff Luck
JPJohn Peabody
John Peabody
Objective : To assess the validity of standardised patients to measure the quality of physicians' practice. Design : Validation study of standardised patients' assessments. Physicians saw unannounced standardised patients presenting with common outpatient conditions. The standardised patients covertly tape recorded their visit and completed a checklist of quality criteria immediately afterwards. Their assessments were compared against independent assessments of the recordings by a trained medical records abstractor. Setting : Four general internal medicine primary care clinics in California. Participants : 144 randomly selected consenting physicians. Main outcome measures : Rates of agreement between the patients' assessments and independent assessment. Results : 40 visits, one per standardised patient, were recorded. The overall rate of agreement between the standardised patients' checklists and the independent assessment of the audio transcripts was 91% (κ. Disaggregating the data by medical condition, site, level of physicians' training, and domain (stage of the consultation) gave similar rates of agreement. Sensitivity of the standardised patients' assessments was 95%, and specificity was 85%. The area under the receiver operator characteristic curve was 90%. Conclusions : Standardised patients' assessments seem to be a valid measure of the quality of physicians' care for a variety of common medical conditions in actual outpatient settings. Properly trained standardised patients compare well with independent assessment of recordings of the consultations and may justify their use as a “gold standard” in comparing the quality of care across sites or evaluating data obtained from other sources, such as medical records and clinical vignettes.

11 November 2015 in Journal of Adolescence
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
KLKatherine Sachs Leventhal
Katherine Sachs Leventhal
JGJane Gillham
Jane Gillham
LDLisa DeMaria
Lisa DeMaria
GAGracy Andrew
Gracy Andrew
JPJohn Peabody
John Peabody
SLSteve Leventhal
Steve Leventhal
We conducted a randomized controlled trial of a 5‐month resilience‐based program (Girls First Resilience Curriculum or RC) among 2308 rural adolescent girls at 57 government schools in Bihar, India. Local women with at least a 10th grade education served as group facilitators. Girls receiving RC improved more (vs. controls) on emotional resilience, self‐efficacy, social‐emotional assets, psychological wellbeing, and social wellbeing. Effects were not detected on depression. There was a small, statistically significant negative effect on anxiety (though not likely clinically significant). Results suggest psychosocial assets and wellbeing can be improved for girls in high‐poverty, rural schools through a brief school‐day program. To our knowledge, this is one of the largest developing country trials of a resilience‐based school‐day curriculum for adolescents.

1 November 2000 in Journal of General Internal Medicine
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
TDTimothy R. Dresselhaus
Timothy R. Dresselhaus
JPJohn Peabody
John Peabody
MLMartin Lee
Martin Lee
MWMing Ming Wang
Ming Ming Wang
JLJeff Luck
Jeff Luck