Residential yards can contribute to urban biodiversity and sustainability, but less is known about how residents’ environmental attitudes and awareness of neighborhood initiatives relate to yard-based environmental actions. Informed by the theory of planned behavior and the New Ecological Paradigm (NEP), this study explored whether environmental attitudes and awareness of neighborhood environmental actions were associated with yard-based environmental improvements in Gainesville, Florida. We analyzed survey data from 106 homeowners in five neighborhoods using principal component analysis and AICc-ranked binomial generalized linear models. Exploratory PCA identified three NEP components associated with environmental actions within yards. Awareness of environmental actions within the neighborhood showed a more consistent positive association with the respondents’ own reported environmental actions across model specifications. The most commonly reported actions were planting native plants, using water-efficient irrigation, and removing invasive plants. Findings highlight the potential importance of both environmental attitudes and visible neighborhood environmental practices in understanding household-level environmental actions.