Geospatial data are fundamental in most global-change and sustainability-related domains. However, readily accessible information on data quality and provenance is often missing or hardly accessible for users due to technical or perceptual barriers, for example, due to unstructured metadata information or missing references. Within an interdisciplinary process encompassing perspectives of data users, data producers, and software developers, we identified major needs to facilitate effective fitness-for-use assessments by data users and developed approaches to address these. We provided a stylized analysis of large-scale land use data to showcase selected approaches. To support data users, interoperable quality and provenance information need to be meaningfully represented. Data producers need efficient workflows and tools supporting them in creating high-quality, structured and detailed quality and provenance information. Our newly developed approaches to increase the availability of structured metadata synthesize new and existing tools to extract metadata or to generate provenance data during processing. Within our approaches to improve interoperability and accessibility we present novel tools to support (i) the creation of curated and linked registers of data quality indicators and thematic terms, and (ii) linked visualization of data quality and provenance information. Following our approaches increases transparency, facilitates fitness-for-use assessments, and ultimately improves research quality.
In Earth System Sciences (ESS), spatial data are increasingly used for impact research and decision-making. To support the stakeholders’ decision, the quality of the spatial data and its assurance play a major role. We present concepts and a workflow to assure the quality of ESS data. Our concepts and workflow are designed along the research data life cycle and include criteria for openness, FAIRness of data (findable, accessible, interoperable, reusable), data maturity, and data quality. Existing data maturity concepts describe (community-specific) maturity matrices, e.g., for meteorological data. These concepts assign a variety of maturity metrics to discrete levels to facilitate evaluation of the data. Moreover, the use of easy-to-understand level numbers enables quick recognition of highly mature data, and hence fosters easier reusability. Here, we propose a revised maturity matrix for ESS data including a comprehensive list of FAIR criteria. To foster the compatibility with the developed maturity matrix approach, we developed a spatial data quality matrix that relates the data maturity levels to quality metrics. The maturity and quality levels are then assigned to the phases of the data life cycle. With implementing openness criteria and matrices for data maturity and quality, we build a quality assurance (QA) workflow that comprises various activities and roles. To support researchers in applying this workflow, we implement an interactive questionnaire in the tool RDMO (research data management organizer) to collaboratively manage and monitor all QA activities. This can serve as a blueprint for use-case-specific QA for other datasets. As a proof of concept, we successfully applied our criteria for openness, data maturity, and data quality to the publicly available SPAM2010 (crop distribution) dataset series.
Web applications in spatial data infrastructures (SDIs) should provide robust and user-friendly user interfaces for geoinformation (GI) discovery, analysis, and usage. Poor usability, e.g., caused by unsuitable information presentation or inappropriate (non) availability of functions, can result in inefficient or faulty usage and can increase the acceptance of the application and provided geoinformation. Until now, a number of usability problems in GI web applications were identified; however, methods to summarize these problems, to provide (software-independent) solutions for them, and to find pairs of problems and related solutions hardly exist. We propose an adapted usability pattern concept for web applications in SDIs to map and categorize usability problems and best practice solutions and we enable a GI context-specific creation and discovery of these problems and solutions. The concept includes developed pattern types, relationships, and rules on how to use the relationships for the different pattern types.
Interactive digital maps are useful for illustrating and analyzing geographic data and are used for diverse purposes (e.g., wayfinding, data journalism, data analysis, and citizen engagement). This article discusses the requirements of intelligent maps from three perspectives: the literature, a user survey, and a reverse-brainstorming workshop. The ideas brought forth are relevant to researchers and designers of digital maps as they incorporate innovative features and strive for a good user experience.
The CODATA Data Science Journal is a peer-reviewed, open access, electronic journal, publishing papers on the management, dissemination, use and reuse of research data and databases across all research domains, including science, technology, the humanities and the arts. The scope of the journal includes descriptions of data systems, their implementations and their publication, applications, infrastructures, software, legal, reproducibility and transparency issues, the availability and usability of complex datasets, and with a particular focus on the principles, policies and practices for open data. All data is in scope, whether born digital or converted from other sources.