A nutating grinding mill, exemplified by the commercial HICOM mill, achieves efficient particle size reduction through the accelerated motion of the material charge within the nutating chamber. This design, characterised by high particle velocities and rapid charge circulation, offers a compact solution compared to tumbling mills. There have been concerns regarding the mechanical reliability of kinetic joints for certain specialised mining applications. Recognising the need to model internal forces in such systems, this study focuses on the uncoupled simulation using multibody dynamics and the discrete element method. The investigation employed a small-scale experimental test mill, referred to as the NuMILL, featuring a cylindrical chamber (140 mm internal diameter, 245 mm height, 6° nutation angle). Instrumented with an array of sensors, the NuMILL provided internal load data for validating the simulations. Experiments were conducted with an empty chamber or filled with charge material. Charge materials included coarse sand or steel pellets with a charge-to-chamber mass ratio of 0.25. The mill speed ranged between 100 to 700 RPM. Multibody dynamics modelled resultant inertial and frictional loads within 5%, while the discrete element method simulated the internal material contact loads with accuracies ranging from 1% to 19%. The combined simulation approach predicted the resultant forces in the critical kinetic joint within a 20% margin. Representing the charge using rigid lumped mass elements was also studied. The presented simulation techniques, validated against experimental data, offer a robust foundation for analysing larger systems, including the industrial-scale HICOM.
10 October 2025 in SolarPACES Conference Proceedings
Traditional concentrating solar power plants utilize silvered glass reflective facets that account for a significant portion of the total plant cost. Several cost-effective non-glass reflectors have been developed. A majority of these novel reflectors are flexible, which necessitates exploring support structures to maintain their shape during use. This study presents a methodology for evaluating and selecting structural support materials for non-glass heliostat facets. The approach employs analytical models to efficiently screen a large pool of candidate materials based on strength, stiffness, and deflection due to gravity, using an existing glass reflector panel as a reference. During analysis, sandwich panels showed promise as viable support for the reflector. The most promising sandwich panel designs are further investigated using experimental testing. The analytical model predictions are found to align moderately well with physical test results, validating its utility for rapid material selection. The top-performing sandwich panel designs demonstrate the potential for cost savings and increased facet size compared to traditional glass facets. This research provides a framework for evaluating and selecting structural materials for non-glass heliostat facets, enabling improved cost-effectiveness and performance of concentrating solar power systems.
Nutating mills offer intense comminution dynamics without the gravitational constraints of conventional tumbling mills; however, their structural response and charge–structure interaction mechanisms remain insufficiently characterized. This work examines the dynamic behavior of a laboratory-scale nutating mill (NuMill) with granular charge through combined experimental characterization and a two-way coupled numerical framework integrating multi-body dynamics (MBD) with the discrete element method (DEM). This study expands on previous work, extending the characterization of the NuMill to include mount stiffness, damping, and charge–structure coupling. The NuMill was adapted with vibration isolation mounts and internal chamber ribs to more closely emulate the operating behavior of industrial Hicom mills. Measurements of forces, torques, and accelerations were obtained across a range of mounting, charge, and chamber geometry configurations. Results show that approximating the granular charge in a ribbed chamber as a rigid body leads to substantial predictive error, overestimating crank-pin forces by 21% and underestimating driveshaft torque by 82% at 700 RPM. Incorporating experimentally characterized stiffness into the coupled MBD–DEM model showed good prediction accuracy for granular charge at 700 RPM. The simulation overestimated crank-pin force by 34%, underestimated driveshaft torque by 25%, and reproduced rigid-body natural frequencies within 1%. These findings demonstrate that structural compliance and charge–structure coupling play a central role in determining operational loads in nutating mills. The validated modeling framework developed here provides a more reliable basis for design assessment and parameter selection in industrial nutating milling applications and extends existing experimental foundations for laboratory-scale systems.
This study investigated the influence of high-strength low-alloy steel on the fatigue life of a load-bearing member with a non-load-bearing transverse welded attachment (T-joint). It compared high cycle fatigue data to two fatigue design codes, namely BS 7608 and Eurocode EN 1993-1-9. Different base and filler material combinations of varying material strengths were investigated, resulting in a total of three different specimen configurations. Two material combinations had a high-strength steel (Strenx® 700 MC D) for the base material, with one combination having a matched filler material and the other having an undermatched filler material. The third material combination had a lower-strength steel (S 355 JR AR) for the base material, with a matched filler material. Tensile tests were performed to confirm the base material mechanical properties and weld quality of the manufactured specimens. The investigation showed that there was no significant benefit to using high-strength steel as the base material for a fatigue loaded T-joint with a non-load-bearing welded attachments.